Who is QB1 v Pitt

[rrlbees]

Why does it have to be one extreme or the other with you? You know a person can be straightforward, acknowledge reality and still be respectful….

He’s probably the QB next week and he’s trying to instill a little confidence in him. Kid is probably down.

 

[tep624]

You don’t crap on a player, ever, as a coach. This is like basic level stuff here.

Saying he sucked is crapping on him.

Saying he has some things to work on and leaving it at that isn’t crapping on him. This isn’t kindergarten.

 

[Cuse181]

Saying he sucked is crapping on him.

Saying he has some things to work on and leaving it at that isn’t crapping on him. This isn’t kindergarten.

Fair, just not sure what value that adds

 

[Cusefan78]

You have to wonder if it is concussion related from the Clemson hit, is Shrader packing it in knowing this is probably the end of the line for his football career. Why risk another blow to the head?

I think it’s the arm he had surgery on. There was a game early in the season where he was shaking it like something was wrong. I’m betting that’s it. That seams to me like that was the start of it. I don’t think that hit during Clemson is the cause

 

[tep624]

Fair, just not sure what value that adds

Putting CDRW aside, I’m just tired of Dino not giving straight answers about obvious things.

 

[Giants1973]

Play Davis kid. See what he can do!!!

 

[Cusefan78]

You don’t crap on a player, ever, as a coach. This is like basic level stuff here.

You just say he had a rough passing day. My god these kids aren’t snowflakes if they are then they shouldn’t be playing d1

 

[PAcuse]

I heard we just signed Dric Eungey to the team...

 

[Cusefan78]

Fair, just not sure what value that adds

It’s called the truth and that has a lot of value.

 

[Cuse181]

You just say he had a rough passing day. My god these kids aren’t snowflakes if they are then they shouldn’t be playing d1

And yet, no one does it because these kids are ego maniacs and they don’t take public criticism well. That’s just how it is. You want to lose a team? Criticizing them publicly is a great way to achieve that. This is the very same board that was up on arms anytime JB was honest about a player.

 

[PAcuse]

Also, no clue how you can guy CDRW out in any game anymore

7/17 37 yards 4 INTs...7.7 QBR

 

[Cusefan78]

And yet, no one does it because these kids are ego maniacs and they don’t take public criticism well. That’s just how it is. You want to lose a team? Criticizing them publicly is a great way to achieve that. This is the very same board that was up on arms anytime JB was honest about a player.

You think those players played hard yesterday. Outside a handful of them they are checked out and have been for weeks. The team needs to be turned over and some discipline needs to be brought in.

 

[tep624]

Also, no clue how you can guy CDRW out in any game anymore

7/17 37 yards 4 INTs...7.7 QBR

I mean a 7.7 QBR is pretty good if you exclude all of the interceptions, add 3 TD passes and 15 more completions.

World according to Dino.

 

[Cuse181]

It’s called the truth and that has a lot of value.

Value to who? do you suddenly not care about losses because Dino said his QB is bad?

 

[Cuse181]

You think those players played hard yesterday. Outside a handful of them they are checked out and have been for weeks. The team needs to be turned over and some discipline needs to be brought in.

Nope, that wasn’t anywhere in my comment. Doesn’t mean it’s okay to destroy a locker room with 3 weeks left. Fans want someone to voice their frustrations for them, and it seems easy when there’s no ramifications on the fans part. Obviously many here are upset, but rationality shouldn’t go out the window because one is mad. A lame duck coach, going after a player who was clearly underprepared, in the face of 5 straight losses (4 blow outs), speaks nothing of the player and everything about the coach.

 

[tbonezone]

You don’t crap on a player, ever, as a coach. This is like basic level stuff here.

and how long you been a cuse fan ?

 

[Fanalways]

You have to wonder if it is concussion related from the Clemson hit, is Shrader packing it in knowing this is probably the end of the line for his football career. Why risk another blow to the head?

Initially I thought concussion, too but I doubt it since he was at the game. Bright lights, noise, etc don't bode well if he had a concussion. It must be his shoulder or something else.

 

[tep624]

Nope, that wasn’t anywhere in my comment. Doesn’t mean it’s okay to destroy a locker room with 3 weeks left. Fans want someone to voice their frustrations for them, and it seems easy when there’s no ramifications on the fans part. Obviously many here are upset, but rationality shouldn’t go out the window because one is mad. A lame duck coach, going after a player who was clearly underprepared, in the face of 5 straight losses (4 blow outs), speaks nothing of the player and everything about the coach.

CDRW has been in the program for over a year. If he’s underprepared whose fault is that?

 

[Cuse181]

CDRW has been in the program for over a year. If he’s underprepared whose fault is that?

The coaches?

 

[SUDadx2]

Play Davis kid. See what he can do!!!

The coaches see what each QB can do every day in practice.

MacPhail played ahead of Davis in a game earlier this season.

The coaches are playing who they think gives us the best chance to win.

 

[tep624]

The coaches?

Precisely. And to try to frame CDRW’s performance as anything more than what it was deflects criticism away from them as well.

 

[Dmcnabbrules]

Honestly MacPhail couldn’t be worse than CDRW. He could be as bad, but not worse. Maybe he can throw the ball past the line of scrimmage to the team with the same color jersey as him.

 

[RICuse44]

Wild cat with villari.

And lequint. Gets price on the field. Villari and Donovan can throw too. Or put one of the bigger backs in w lequint. Anything that gives the offense a chance. As is they do not have one with a hobbled/unhobbled cdrw

 

[Cuse181]

Precisely. And to try to frame CDRW’s performance as anything more than what it was deflects criticism away from them as well.

Which is why it was good dino didn’t say CDRW played poorly

 

[NCo’range]

You have to wonder if it is concussion related from the Clemson hit, is Shrader packing it in knowing this is probably the end of the line for his football career. Why risk another blow to the head?

Well apparently it wasn't the Clemson hit according to this.