You are focusing on the three or four that we lost. Look at the recruits we have gotten, especially the last few years. To them, SU was obviously their dream school. You gotta look at both sides of the ledger. Also, how about kids that we didn't take where we might have been their dream school. All in all, I gotta believe that if a kids says we are one of his dream school it increases our chances.
In the cases of Hodge & Marbury it went beyond us being a theoretical dream school. The thinking was that they would be coming here & that is why losing them hurt so much. As for Lamb, yeah, I remember us being in the mix, but that was about it. I am nit sure that we were ever really the leader for him. And then you have the Wroten's of the world who had a dream school a week. Do you even bother to count them ?