Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="bpo57, post: 1889986, member: 1572"] YOU feel he should be judged in comparison to other second basemen. I'm telling you I think there will be many writers that won't do that. Plenty of these guys use certain benchmarks (hits, HRs, RBIs, postseason success, etc.) to define HoF worthiness. Either way there is no set criteria that says he should only be compared to second basemen. If he doesn't breach 3,000 or 400 then he may not get in even though he compares very favorably to second basemen overall. [/QUOTE]