2025 MLB Season | Page 4 | Syracusefan.com

2025 MLB Season

No love for Jeremy Peña?
I was looking for him under second base instead of SS and was surprised he wasn't listed. Oops! I'll probably do a second set of picks as we get closer to the deadline.
 
I was looking for him under second base instead of SS and was surprised he wasn't listed. Oops! I'll probably do a second set of picks as we get closer to the deadline.
It is a tough year for sure. Some of these guys are separated by fractions of WAR. I’m going to wait another week or two and hope more distance is created.
 
Should we start to ask "questions" about how the Atlanta Braves hit the ball so well in 2023. The Braves in 2023 had a historic year offensively, where they had an OPS+ of 126... no other team was above 116 that year. 8 of the 9 starters on the team performed well above their recent average in other years between 2021-2025, and all 9 performed better.

Here are the average OPS of the 9 starters the Braves had in 2023, vs how those same 9 players performed in their other recent years.
2021 - 97
2022 - 108
2023 - 130
2024 - 98
2025 - 103

(Note for 2025, 2 of the 2023 players had played very little in 2025 (no longer start), so I used their 2024 OPS.

By player, here is their 2023 OPS compared to their average of 2021/22/24/25.
Eddie Rosario +45%
Ronald Acuna +36%
Ozzie Albies +33%
Orlando Arcia +31%
Matt Olson +27%
Sean Murphy +24%
Michael Harris +15%
Marcell Ozuna +12%
Austin Riley +2%

Something up, or other factor like random luck / bad coaching adjustments?
 
Last edited:
Should we start to ask "questions" about how the Atlanta Braves hit the ball so well in 2023. The Braves in 2023 had a historic year offensively, where they had an OPS+ of 126... no other team was above 116 that year. Almost every starter on the team performed well above their recent average in other years between 2021-2025.

Here are the average OPS of the 9 starters the Braves had in 2023, vs how those same 9 players performed in their other recent years.
2021 - 97
2022 - 108
2023 - 130
2024 - 98
2025 - 103

(Note for 2025, 2 of the 2023 players had played very little in 2025 (no longer start), so I used their 2024 OPS.

By player, here is their 2023 OPS compared to their average of 2021/22/24/25.
Eddie Rosario +45%
Ronald Acuna +36%
Ozzie Albies +33%
Orlando Arcia +31%
Matt Olson +27%
Sean Murphy +24%
Michael Harris +15%
Marcell Ozuna +12%
Austin Riley +2%

Something up, or other factor like random luck / bad coaching adjustments?
That’s baseball Suzyn
 
Should we start to ask "questions" about how the Atlanta Braves hit the ball so well in 2023. The Braves in 2023 had a historic year offensively, where they had an OPS+ of 126... no other team was above 116 that year. Almost every starter on the team performed well above their recent average in other years between 2021-2025.

Here are the average OPS of the 9 starters the Braves had in 2023, vs how those same 9 players performed in their other recent years.
2021 - 97
2022 - 108
2023 - 130
2024 - 98
2025 - 103

(Note for 2025, 2 of the 2023 players had played very little in 2025 (no longer start), so I used their 2024 OPS.

By player, here is their 2023 OPS compared to their average of 2021/22/24/25.
Eddie Rosario +45%
Ronald Acuna +36%
Ozzie Albies +33%
Orlando Arcia +31%
Matt Olson +27%
Sean Murphy +24%
Michael Harris +15%
Marcell Ozuna +12%
Austin Riley +2%

Something up, or other factor like random luck / bad coaching adjustments?
Did they get a former Houston coach in 2023?
 
That’s baseball Suzyn

You will not find anything close to these outliers across an entire team since1980 for sure (when I got into baseball), and probably not even in MLB History . Whether its nefarious or not, or just coaching adjustments or random luck, this sort of outlier across an entire team has never happened.

It's not just "that's baseball" when its a one time thing.
 
Last edited:
You will not find anything close to these outliers across an entire team since1980 for sure (when I got into baseball), and probably not even in MLB History
You checked every team since 1980? You must be a man of leisure. ;)

I am curious how this works out with a better stat than OPS+, but I don’t have the motivation to do the homework.
 
You checked every team since 1980? You must be a man of leisure. ;)

I am curious how this works out with a better stat than OPS+, but I don’t have the motivation to do the homework.
Ops+ is a pretty all encompassing stat that is normalized for the era you play in
 
Ops+ is a pretty all encompassing stat that is normalized for the era you play in
I know what it is. It is flawed because it weighs slugging and on-base equally. Plus slugging is hugely flawed. Is a double truly twice as valuable than a single? Nope. wRC+ is not perfect either, but it is definitely better.
 
Well this is huge.
Pretty shocking. I know Devers has been a bit of a handful with his frustration over his position, but they sure moved him out pretty fast
 
Well this is huge.
Major shock for me. Not shocked that the FO didn’t get much for him. Not shocked that they “didn’t shop him,” so they had no clue what they might have gotten for him. I thought the refusal to ‘reassign’ to DH was half his fault and half ownership/the manager/GM’s fault. They didn’t communicate well or effectively. And if they indeed told him to ‘throw away his mit,’ when it came time to consider a switch back to the field to play first… well, they had already screwed the situation and led him into the malcontent role.

That all said, I never read that he was a poison to the actual teammates or in the clubhouse. Can’t make a move like this ‘on principle’ (not a team player) when the management was partially culpable, and the move makes you a worse team.

Hope they have something lined up for the trade deadline, where we aren’t sellers. It’s getting very difficult to remain a Sawx fan. At this point, after being devoted since 1976, and watching 90%+ of the games since streaming happened, I now feel like I’m just a fan of the building—Fenway. They ‘lost/chased’ Mookie, Xander, and now Devers. That’s a lot of loss to sustain for a fan.

Oh, man—just remembered we go to SanFran to play against him and the Giants on Friday... That'll be... fun.
 
Last edited:
Major shock for me. Not shocked that the FO didn’t get much for him. Not shocked that they “didn’t shop him,” so they had no clue what they might have gotten for him. I thought the refusal to ‘reassign’ to DH was half his fault and half ownership/the manager/GM’s fault. They didn’t communicate well or effectively. And if they indeed told him to ‘throw away his mit,’ when it came time to consider a switch back to the field to play first… well, they had already screwed the situation and led him into the malcontent role.

That all said, I never read that he was a poison to the actual teammates or in the clubhouse. Can’t make a move like this ‘on principle’ (not a team player) when the management was partially culpable, and the move makes you a worse team.

Hope they have something lined up for the trade deadline, where we aren’t sellers. It’s getting very difficult to remain a Sawx fan. At this point, after being devoted since 1976, and watching 90%+ of the games since streaming happened, I now feel like I’m just a fan of the building—Fenway. They ‘lost/chased’ Mookie, Xander, and now Devers. That’s a lot of loss to sustain for a fan.

Oh, man—just remembered we go to SanFran to play against him and the Giants on Friday... That'll be... fun.
They're sellers.
Chapman is probably next.
 
They're sellers.
Chapman is probably next.
Prolly.
Ridiculous, though, that a team with its resources should be in this position, not just now, but in the last five years. The search for the GM—the role Breslow now has—was portentous. They couldn't get anyone on their list to even come in for an interview. I blame Henry, and even though i like Cora, i am not convinced he's the kind of manager we need.
 
Prolly.
Ridiculous, though, that a team with its resources should be in this position, not just now, but in the last five years. The search for the GM—the role Breslow now has—was portentous. They couldn't get anyone on their list to even come in for an interview. I blame Henry, and even though i like Cora, i am not convinced he's the kind of manager we need.
I like Breslow overall.

Adding a 3B (Bergman) soon after signing Devers (the 3B at the time) to a $300M contract wasn’t the smartest move.
Different GM; different promises.
They’re going to give Bregman a ridiculous contract this winter.

John Henry wants to leverage the enormous value of the Red Sox to get an NBA team in Las Vegas. Maybe when that comes true, he’ll finally sell the team and I can enjoy the Red Sox again.
 
Major shock for me. Not shocked that the FO didn’t get much for him. Not shocked that they “didn’t shop him,” so they had no clue what they might have gotten for him. I thought the refusal to ‘reassign’ to DH was half his fault and half ownership/the manager/GM’s fault. They didn’t communicate well or effectively. And if they indeed told him to ‘throw away his mit,’ when it came time to consider a switch back to the field to play first… well, they had already screwed the situation and led him into the malcontent role.

That all said, I never read that he was a poison to the actual teammates or in the clubhouse. Can’t make a move like this ‘on principle’ (not a team player) when the management was partially culpable, and the move makes you a worse team.

Hope they have something lined up for the trade deadline, where we aren’t sellers. It’s getting very difficult to remain a Sawx fan. At this point, after being devoted since 1976, and watching 90%+ of the games since streaming happened, I now feel like I’m just a fan of the building—Fenway. They ‘lost/chased’ Mookie, Xander, and now Devers. That’s a lot of loss to sustain for a fan.

Oh, man—just remembered we go to SanFran to play against him and the Giants on Friday... That'll be... fun.
You make several good points. I think ownership/FO is at least partly to blame for this situation. The only way this move will work is if they get solid production from one of the pitchers and they wisely and fully invest the Devers $$$ to beef up the roster, particularly the pitching.

I've always felt the Sox took too much heat for Betts. He made it abundantly clear he didn't want to stay in Boston. No amount of $$ was going to keep him there. Bogaerts has seriously underperformed his contract. You could kinda see that coming. Sox dodged a bullet there.
 
Last year, in April, I said that the mets would sign Soto and the Red Sox would acquire Crochet in a trade. No kidding. I think the Sox will take a hard run at Skenes in the off season. Incredibly, the Pirates will trade him and want minor leaguers in return. But my main point is that one guy I hoped the Sox could get was Kyle Harrison. I didn't know it would be Devers which considering the timing shocked me. If the Sox can stay in the wild card race through this coming 8 games, they will go out and get a right handed bat.
 
Move them out.
Get considerably less in return.
Feed people in media that the player was difficult.

That's the Red Sox way.
You don't think Devers was difficult? A total child that was not a good teammate. Not running balls out. Refusing to play a position because his feelings were hurt. Terrific hitter. Wish it could have worked out. But a very bad influence on the younger guys on this team which is just about everyone. And lest we forget, before this ownership group came in, we went 86 years without a title. We have won 4 in the last 21 years. I think Henry didn't want to spend good money after bad. The Sox have build up their farm system and I think he will spend money to get the team over the top in the next few years. The ownership group flew to K.C. to try to make things right with Devers. Sometimes things don't work out.
 
Move them out.
Get considerably less in return.
Feed people in media that the player was difficult.

That's the Red Sox way.
The narrative of Devers being “difficult” wasn’t exclusive to the Sox brass telling it to the media. Devers dug his own hole with his own words and actions/non-actions. I can understand being upset by the monthslong chatter about the team possibly acquiring Bregman or Arenado, and then the deceit in saying Bregman would play second, and then having him spend almost zero time in ST at second and then giving him third and telling Devers to throw away his glove. Sure, that would upset someone who had pride in playing the field and not being a hit only guy. Sure. But he’s still making 300 million to play baseball. Even with FU money, he’s still an employee and a teammate with a prime objective to win games and championships.

Then when Casas went down and he didn’t jump up and raise his hand to volunteer… i can understand lingering feelings. But again, a good person and a good teammate would have. He isn’t that. I can, though, appreciate some of what he said: that he can’t just leap into an entirely new position. Again, a person of pride didn’t want to be embarrassed again, in an entirely new way—by failing (again, by being a bad 1B as well as a bad 3B). But, again, you gotta try.

It should have been a lesson to him to see all of his other teammates playing multiple positions—even when they had very little previous experience there. But, he was already too far down into his self pity hole and too prideful to reach for a hand to pull himself out. And still, although I ‘hate’ all of those perspectives he held, I can understand them.

What just severed all sentiment I had for him was what I just read on SOSH, from someone who is respected as being plugged in: Devers got upset with Campbell for quickly/easily volunteeering to work out at first. Made him look bad? Well, that (if true) represents that Devers is not just prideful and wounded. He’s an abject moron and an a-hole. I wasn’t down with the corporate line that they had to get rid of him because he didn’t lead like a $300m guy, only because it’s still the GM’s duty to field the most competitive team and this move makes the team worse, way before the deadline when such decisions need to be made. And because they didn’t shop him, and because Henry rejected a deal that may have been better because he didn’t want to spend money on the ostensibly better players return. But if that last bit was true, yeah, you had to do it.

On the other side of things, there was talk about Devers not running out certain grounders, but Cora said he had been dealing with some g-g-g-groin stuff. And after that egregious pull up, a couple of days later, the commentators said that he was feeling much better and in that game he did hustle down the line. In the next game, he didn’t hustle, and I surmised he had overdone it that previous game and was back to feeling not so good again.

Thank goodness for the pitching during this recent stretch of games:

IMG_4721.jpeg
 
Devers was getting jerked around by Cora and the front office. Bloom gives him basically a lifetime contract. Bloom (and his promises) are kicked to the curb. New GM kicks Devers square in the crotch and decides that what this team really needs is a second All-star 3B. Devers is told to play DH. He is told to play 1B.
He didn't handle the pressure well but it's crazy to pretend that the front office didn't create this mess.

The Red Sox are seen as a dysfunctional organization. Whose fault is that?
They have a long history of crapping on people on the way out.
When the Red Sox fell apart in 2011 and they were getting rid of Tito, stories about him abusing pills and his marriage troubles suddenly appearing in the news.
Mookie has said repeatedly that he wanted to stay in Boston but stories kept being written that he wanted to leave.
If you listened to that press conference last night, it was the usual bs. They're committed to winning and building off their impressive 37-36 record. (Of course, they just traded away the best hitter on the team and one of the best in baseball.)

The annual rebuild continues.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
174,576
Messages
5,169,628
Members
6,140
Latest member
Scooter#23

Online statistics

Members online
153
Guests online
2,337
Total visitors
2,490


...
Top Bottom