As a baseball nut, I want to see it happen no matter what the obstacles. Someone who doesn't like baseball is going to use any excuse possible because they want to see every last dollar go to the football or basketball program. So this debate is not an easy one when looking purely at what direction to go in when it comes to what is better for the school.
-Weather or travel doesn't cause much of a problem to me. Plenty of northern schools have successfully laid the blueprint there, and especially if Uconn goes to the ACC with us, we would make it at least 3 northern programs that will be joining a fourth (BC) in the new conference.
-Recruiting, again, not worried there. In this year's draft 28 players were drafted out of NY HS or college programs, 29 the year before that, and 26 before that and so on. This doesn't include what is probably a large number of HS and JUCO kids who leave the state to play elsewhere.
-This is not HS, where you get the limited number of good athletes trying to decide whether or not to play baseball or lacrosse. For our purposes they are two totally separate entities, so I really don't think anyone needs to take sides in that manner.
-The field issue may be a tough one, but I think fusing the two ideas together of utilizing an on-campus field and ABS could be great for building the foundation of a program. When the Chiefs are out of town, Syracuse has its games at ABS. When the Chiefs are in town, an Orange/Chiefs double-header would be awesome. Obviously some logistics problems arise, so you do need the on-campus field handy, but if they can be paved over I think that would be a great way to provide an event for the fans that maximize their limited budgets. Also, at some point a decision on the Dome will have to happen. WHEN however, will probably be decided by the economy, the success of our football team, and how much cash the ACC actually provides. But if a renovation or rebuild takes place ten or fifteen years down the road, you have the time to develop a competitive program, and then the opportunity to take that competitive program and boost it to elite levels if the "new Dome" can be configured for baseball too.
-As with everything, the biggest obstacle has to do with initial funding. I think the program can take care of itself, but the added costs of evening out the men's and women's sports make it more of an up-front gamble. A deep study into donors, ACC perks, etc. etc. may paint a clearer picture, but I think most of the other issues are way down on the totem pole.