Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Melancer46, post: 2068319, member: 1674"] As I said, I don't factor Super Bowls or wins into much at all, so most of what you said doesn't really change my mind at all. 7 All-Pro 1st team selections for Peyton versus 2 for Brady is also a huge difference for me. Starting when Brady really became the centerpiece of the Patriots offense (2002) to 2014 (the year before Peyton's final season when he was just a complete shell of himself), I'd say Peyton was better 8 or 9 times. Brady was better 2 or 3 times. And then I excluded two seasons in which one of them missed the whole year (2008 for Brady and 2011 for Peyton). [/QUOTE]