Awesome WVU Marching Band Performance | Syracusefan.com

Awesome WVU Marching Band Performance

Yeah, as much as I dislike the inbreds, I gotta admit that was cool.
 
Wow...it is beyond SU's Marching Band..it was very intricate.

To me, this isn't any more or less intricate than anything the SUMB does. What makes this show so cool boils down to two things.

1) The show concept. As obvious and fun as this show was, it's actually really hard to draw up something like this and even harder to execute it. WVU had a novel idea and made it work. The SUMB hasn't had a novel idea in a long time.

2) The band's size. When you've got more than 350 members, you can do so much more than with a band that has maybe 150 members, like SU's.

The SUMB could certainly pull something like this off. They'd just need to think of it first.
 
This is real cool.

I gotta say when my kids ask me what the SU marching band is making when they do their formations other than the NYS one I usually look for a bit and say, "Another ameba." I have no clue what they are ever trying make - no idea at all. My kids give their views but it ends up like all of us are staring at abstract art and everyone comes up with different meanings.
 
I gotta say when my kids ask me what the SU marching band is making when they do their formations other than the NYS one I usually look for a bit and say, "Another ameba." I have no clue what they are ever trying make - no idea at all. My kids give their views but it ends up like all of us are staring at abstract art and everyone comes up with different meanings.

The SUMB tries to stick to a type of marching band that doesn't really fit. Their style is much too High School, too formal. Let me explain.

The point of HS marching band, especially in competitive circuits like Upstate New York, is to execute with precision. A good band is trying to move in formations that allow them to showcase an ability to create straight lines, curves, diagonals, and other angles. At the same time, the band is also trying to show an ability to move from formation to formation in a specific number of notes, all hitting at the same time.

A good high school marching band is constantly moving for seven straight minutes. The need to keep moving and the need to show different abilities means a band is usually creating abstract shapes that aren't supposed to look like anything.

The SUMB does the same thing, and I don't know why. Most college marching bands don't move very often. Their purpose is to play loud and to be fun. Our band doesn't really do that. Instead, it tries to keep moving, and therefore keeps trying to be a high school marching band.

That's why we don't see many fun shapes or unique concepts.
 
Found link on Rutgers Rivals Board

Wow...it is beyond SU's Marching Band..it was very intricate.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MjPmmCtHmfE&feature=youtu.be

Yep, agree. Awesome performance!

Not a musician, but through many years of watching the SU band, both in-person and on TV or U-Tube, I always felt that:

1. It isn't loud enough because it isn't large enough.

2. It doesn't really get the crowd stirred-up. To me, the crowd has to "feel" and be moved by the music along with the band. In general, I don't think this happens often enough with the SU band.

2. When it comes to marching bands, especially at events like fb games, I'm partial to upbeat/uptempo stuff. It's not the same as when the band gives a concert-type performance where varying the tempo with more classical and fewer upbeat arrangements is appropriate.

It's been that way for as long as I can remember. I don't know who does the arrangements or who the band director is, but I'd love to seen them "jazz" things up more and really get the crowd pumped-up and rocking. But I guess that's tough to do with a band this size unless you have an above-average group of musicians who are also great on their feet and the right mix of instruments. Tall order, I know, especially for a school the size of SU.
 
Hi guys,

I’m the director of the SUMB, and I wanted to chime in here; you guys are the biggest SU fans I can find on the Internet!

The SUMB does shows like this a lot. The WVU show linked here is an Armed Forces salute; we did the same thing in 2003 and again in 2007. We don’t have enough personnel to do as much as they did (I personally love the boat turning into a sub and the water rising to cover it) but we spelled the names of all the branches (“Army”, “Navy”, etc.) and made tanks, ships and planes and moved them around the field. For perspective, WVU has over 400 members, ad we have around 200. The SUMB has grown by about 50 members in the last 5-7 years, and we are always working to increase the size of it but without scholarships for any band members it can be difficult.

Last season, in 2010, we did a mash-up of the best pop music from 2000-2010 and spelled bands’ names and made their logos on the field. This year, we made stars, flags, and other patriotic images in our salute to 9/11. At the Pinstripe Bowl, our New York-themed show had us making the Manhattan skyline and the Statue of Liberty.

These are just some of the examples I can think of off-hand of the specific shapes we made on the field recently, and they don’t include our pregame show which features a giant “S” going down the field to the fight song and an entire routine in the shape of New York. When you see us making abstract shapes (some of them do look like amoebas, we see that too!) it’s because we’re concerned with staging our players: that is, we need the right sections in the right place at the right time so you can hear them. This can result is shapes/forms that look like abstract art.

I don’t think we move more than most FBS college bands (if we do, it’s only by a bit); every school moves about as much we do, and makes abstract shapes when there isn’t a special show theme like this. Don’t forget that we recruit most of our students in the northeast and they are accustomed and versed in a certain marching style and we can’t move too far away from that or it will be even more difficult to get them to join.

We are always looking for ways to innovate to give you fans something exciting, too. This year’s mash-up of Karaoke classics with singers and lyrics on the scoreboard was a big hit, as was last year’s decade show. We also dance too; we did the “Single Ladies” dance last year and made a huge splash with “Thriller” a few years ago right after Michael Jackson’s passing.

In any case, thank for being interested in college bands and I promise that as an SU alum, my staff and I are working tirelessly to grow and improve the SUMB to help give our team the best home field advantage in college football and to provide our fans with a fun and memorable gameday experience. There is nothing more important to us than those two goals. Go Orange!
 
Hi guys,

I’m the director of the SUMB, and I wanted to chime in here; you guys are the biggest SU fans I can find on the Internet!

The SUMB does shows like this a lot. The WVU show linked here is an Armed Forces salute; we did the same thing in 2003 and again in 2007. We don’t have enough personnel to do as much as they did (I personally love the boat turning into a sub and the water rising to cover it) but we spelled the names of all the branches (“Army”, “Navy”, etc.) and made tanks, ships and planes and moved them around the field. For perspective, WVU has over 400 members, ad we have around 200. The SUMB has grown by about 50 members in the last 5-7 years, and we are always working to increase the size of it but without scholarships for any band members it can be difficult.

Last season, in 2010, we did a mash-up of the best pop music from 2000-2010 and spelled bands’ names and made their logos on the field. This year, we made stars, flags, and other patriotic images in our salute to 9/11. At the Pinstripe Bowl, our New York-themed show had us making the Manhattan skyline and the Statue of Liberty.

These are just some of the examples I can think of off-hand of the specific shapes we made on the field recently, and they don’t include our pregame show which features a giant “S” going down the field to the fight song and an entire routine in the shape of New York. When you see us making abstract shapes (some of them do look like amoebas, we see that too!) it’s because we’re concerned with staging our players: that is, we need the right sections in the right place at the right time so you can hear them. This can result is shapes/forms that look like abstract art.

I don’t think we move more than most FBS college bands (if we do, it’s only by a bit); every school moves about as much we do, and makes abstract shapes when there isn’t a special show theme like this. Don’t forget that we recruit most of our students in the northeast and they are accustomed and versed in a certain marching style and we can’t move too far away from that or it will be even more difficult to get them to join.

We are always looking for ways to innovate to give you fans something exciting, too. This year’s mash-up of Karaoke classics with singers and lyrics on the scoreboard was a big hit, as was last year’s decade show. We also dance too; we did the “Single Ladies” dance last year and made a huge splash with “Thriller” a few years ago right after Michael Jackson’s passing.

In any case, thank for being interested in college bands and I promise that as an SU alum, my staff and I are working tirelessly to grow and improve the SUMB to help give our team the best home field advantage in college football and to provide our fans with a fun and memorable gameday experience. There is nothing more important to us than those two goals. Go Orange!

Thanks for your response, SUMB. It's always good to get an honest/non-defensive appraisal from the "horse's mouth". :)
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,434
Messages
4,891,153
Members
5,998
Latest member
powdersmack

Online statistics

Members online
290
Guests online
1,265
Total visitors
1,555


...
Top Bottom