1 save on 9 goals. Would be crazy not to pull him. We were still trying to win the game and a win would have given us a better seed. He has never been pulled because before then he has never done anything remotely close to that bad in goal before. And what was the flack in his press conference? His comments were totally fine! He was complimentary to Mark as a competitor, also puts blame on the rest of the defense for not applying pressure, and said he would certainly be ready for the next one. Only is talking about him because the press people asked him about pulling Mark directly.
It is a mental position, but you have to assume that pulling a struggling goalie in one game is not going to totally ruin their confidence for the rest of the year. We had to try something new in goal for that Duke game with the start Mark had. He rode with Mark despite him struggling in the Towson game, a playoff game with everything on the line. Shows he still supported the guy. If he pulled him early again against Towson I may agree with you.
I wasn't able to watch that game live. The highlights showed the following:
0-1 Kol fell asleep on Williams and he buries an unmolested rip from left wing
0-2 McAdorey blows by Kol (he blows by everyone) and dunks it from the doorstep
0-3 Man down unit gives up a ~14 yard step down rip from up top
0-4 McAdorey beats Caccamo from the wing and cranks coming across the middle (Mark maybe could've saved it but McAdorey had his hands completely free with no contact)
0-5 Sloat SU LSM (37?) was slow to pick him up coming out of the box, took a bad angle on Sloat's dodge (perhaps expecting help or a switch) and Sloat unloads an overhand rip running full steam straight down the middle of the restraining box (no slide).
2-6 McAdorey left completely wide open on right wing for a 10 yard low to high crank (definite miscommunication as to who had slide responsibility between close D & SSDM)
2-7 O'Neil bounce shot as he's dodging on Dwan. Not bad defense, first shot Mark should've saved.
2-8 Williams man up goal from left GLE (low angle). Mark got a piece of the bouncer but it got through
2-9 Mitchell left wide open on the crease by Jake Spallina for an easy dunk from a McAdorey feed from X.
As an ex-defenseman, I have a hard time saying 2 man up goals, 2 door step dunks, 3 wide open rips are Mark not seeing the ball well. McAdorey's goal to make it 0-4 used Caccamo as a slight screen but probably could've been saved. O'Neil's bounce shot to make it 2-7 should've been saved.
Everything else was really poor defensive support. The first goal McAdorey scored on McCool was more of the same - he beats his guy and nobody slid as he got topside from inside 10 yards to score a low bouncer far post.
Now if Mark were a first year goalie or young in his career, I could see a coach saying, "Not your fault and I'm not letting you get shell'd by crappy D." But Mark as a fifth year guy should've probably been given the full first half.