To continue on your line of thought, GMAC could have convinced the top 5-10 players in the transfer portal and there would be several posters that would say he did not do a good job or Hodgsen did better or GMAC does not know what he is doing? There will be haters (actually more now than anytime before and there have been tons in JAB last years and throughout AA’s tenure). GMAC was fortunate that he was not JAB’s successor because I doubt he would have survived the stress back then.
Hopefully, the haters will give GMAC a chance (more than a year) to be successful in the ever changing transfer portal era. Even if he is successful early (this year) he will be criticized for roster retention if any player leaves for the money.