This is tough...
Dion- kid oozed toughness and swagger. You could tell that he thought that he was better than the unfortunate schlub who had to guard him.
Devo - if for nothing else than for the Seton Hall BET game, and his sword dance thing. IMO, truly great teams need a little swagger and attitude.
Scoop - if, after his sophomore year, someone told me that Scoop would be one of my all-time favorites, I would have laughed at them. Kid bled orange, and he grew so much as a player and as a person during his time at SU.
Andy - he improved as much during his time at SU as any player that I can remember. Looked like an choir boy, but he was a tough SOB.
BMK - he epitomized the phrase "student-athlete" - he represented SU with class and honor, and truly seemed to savor every moment, experience and opportunity while at SU. Like Scoop, I'm pretty sure he has some orange in his blood.