The community work is a big deal and I commend her for that. Didn't/isn't Yale go/going through something very similar and it turned out well? Very, and that's the model for this. What kid wants to go to a semi-selective, highly-expensive, average private university if that university is in a decaying Rust Belt town? There are too many Boston Colleges and George Washingtons out there competing for students. Chancy Nancy's way ahead of the game on this one.
Ranking is debatable. There is a ton of politics involved, after all. What really bothered me was losing AAU. And she blew it off like it was meaningless. Very disappointing considering she came from multiple B10 schools, where AAU is considered very important. All she had to do was maintain a bare minimum to stay AAU. It's very unlikely we will ever be able to get that back. She couldn't and we won't - SU hasn't got a medical school. The AAU made it very clear that member institutions without medical schools would not be members in coming years; rather than get expelled, SU opted for the preemptive break-up. And you can bet that she didn't find it meaningless, but it wouldn't do for the Chancellor to let fly with any "sky is falling" quotes about that - she's got to cast it in the most postivie light possible.