Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Zack80, post: 4468203, member: 1245"] I guess these rankings are not terrible, but they have a number of flaws to them. One thing is they seem to have a disdain for goalies, having only #16 Entenmann, #20 McNaney, and #48 Paquette. Last year in their mixed top 50 they had no goalies for the men. Perhaps, they look at the save pcts and see that they are down as compared with the 10 years ago, but you have all these extra year seniors hanging around - so goalie save pcts should be down. They also allow some amount of diving at the goal, which usually ends in a goal or a crease violation, but rarely a save. I don't know what these bumpkins at IL were watching on Memorial Day weekend, but McNaney certainly showed why having a hot goalie is a big thing. I think Powellfan's rankings of McNaney at #6 and Entenmann at #11 are much more reasonable, and I think having 2 or 3 more goalies in the top 50 would also be more reasonable. [/QUOTE]