In some shocking news Rosen and Darnold declare for draft.

[Deano]

About as shocking as Barkley declaring over the weekend too.

 

[NJCuse97]

Real question is; which of that three do the Giants take?

 

[kcsu]

I hope none trade down buy a free agent. I dont think either one of these guys make it.

 

[NJCuse97]

I hope none trade down buy a free agent. I dont think either one of these guys make it.

So no to Barkley also?

 

[kcsu]

So no to Barkley also?

No to Barkley also. Id rather see us load up on picks and go free agent. Rookie QBs work out about 20% of the time.

 

[orangenauburn]

Those QBs are going to be busts.

Barkley, if healthy, can have a good career. But I would not take him top 5. He won't be that much of a difference maker to warrant the money he will get being drafted 4th.

 

[CIL]

No to Barkley also. Id rather see us load up on picks and go free agent. Rookie QBs work out about 20% of the time.

Worked well for Cleveland.

 

[kcsu]

Worked well for Cleveland.

Cleveland would finish last with New England's roster.

 

[qdawgg]

Cleveland would finish last with New England's roster.

LOL

 

[Tobias Funke]

Regardless of what QB is picked if they are drafted into a position where they play early the odds are against them. It is rare that a QB enters the NFL and plays year one and has sustainable success. Hopefully whoever your team is they can plan for the future and mold their future QB behind a good one.

On a side note it is amazing to me that in this world there are literally only about 15 guys who can play NFL QB at a moderately good to great level.

 

[texascpa]

Regardless of what QB is picked if they are drafted into a position where they play early the odds are against them. It is rare that a QB enters the NFL and plays year one and has sustainable success. Hopefully whoever your team is they can plan for the future and mold their future QB behind a good one.

On a side note it is amazing to me that in this world there are literally only about 15 guys who can play NFL QB at a moderately good to great level.

Blame college offenses.

 

[orange_in_VA]

I would take Barkley over either of the QBs. Kid is a legit stud. Too many questions about the QBs.

 

[MadNY3]

I would take Barkley over either of the QBs. Kid is a legit stud. Too many questions about the QBs.

As a Giants fan, we need Rosen more than Barkley. Unless the Giants go bonkers and get Cousins - which I'd be shocked to see - they need to go QB and then fix the OL, LBs.

 

[CIL]

I love how half the board is calling Rosen and Darnold busts...Rosen is one of the best QB prospects to come out since Luck. I remember when some here thought Nassib was a first rounder.

It’s a QB centric league folks. As great as Barkley is, it’s tough to run in the NFL against 8 man fronts. Look at Gurley last year vs this year...

 

[Bayside44]

As a Giants fan, we need Rosen more than Barkley. Unless the Giants go bonkers and get Cousins - which I'd be shocked to see - they need to go QB and then fix the OL, LBs.

The idea of taking a RB over a QB - esp with that line - is nuts.

 

[JrodCuse]

Pretty sure that Gettleman is going to fix the OL via mid round draft picks and free agency.

Eli will probably be our QB for another 2 years. During that time Davis Webb keeps getting groomed.

Take the stud RB. Saquan is a monster. If you really want a QB as well this year, take Lamar Jackson or Baker Mayfield in the 2nd round and let them battle it out with Webb over the next 2 years to see who is Eli's heir apparent.

Look at what the last few top pick RB's have done for their teams. Fournette helped Jacksonville a lot this year. Gurley is Gurley. The cowboys without Zeke are a joke. When was the last time the Giants have had that holy crap stud RB? It's been a loooooong time.

 

[Newhouser]

I like the kid from USC. Struggled this year but he's got tools.

 

[MadNY3]

Pretty sure that Gettleman is going to fix the OL via mid round draft picks and free agency.

Eli will probably be our QB for another 2 years. During that time Davis Webb keeps getting groomed.

Take the stud RB. Saquan is a monster. If you really want a QB as well this year, take Lamar Jackson or Baker Mayfield in the 2nd round and let them battle it out with Webb over the next 2 years to see who is Eli's heir apparent.

Look at what the last few top pick RB's have done for their teams. Fournette helped Jacksonville a lot this year. Gurley is Gurley. The cowboys without Zeke are a joke. When was the last time the Giants have had that holy crap stud RB? It's been a loooooong time.

Why do we think Webb is the heir apparent?

 

[orange79]

Why do we think Webb is the heir apparent?

Because McAdoo didn't?