Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Pyle, post: 2025464, member: 137"] Millen hasn't been there since 2008, the Lions problems go way deeper. Caldwell is the first Lions coach to have a winning record in Detroit since 1972. They also couldn't score a TD in their wildcard game this weekend with Stafford, Tate, Johnson, and Boldin. Does that mean Caldwell is a bad coach? Given the fact he's actually gotten this crappy team to 2 playoff appearances in 3 years then I say no. Based on your critieria for McCarthy, is Caldwell a good coach or not? First winning coach in Detroit in 40 years but lost to the Packers twice this year, got slammed by Dallas and NYG, and couldn't score a TD in their playoff game. I can tell you what, I don't want him gone, that's for sure. [/QUOTE]