Jack McCallum revises NBA's all-time top 50 | Page 2 | Syracusefan.com

Jack McCallum revises NBA's all-time top 50

Originally basketball was a purely team sport, with the players doing maneuvers like "the weave" to to try to get to the basket, (Naismith's first concept had the players on a grid and they were not allowed out of their 'box': the had to pass it from one box to another until the ball got close enough to the basket for someone to shoot, (this could accommodate an entire gym class in one game).

Then, as the game loosened up and the natural talent of the players came out. It became obvious that some players were a good deal better than others and they became 'stars'. The idea was to get a star player and if the other team didn't have one, you would win. If they did, it would be your star trying to out-score their star. The Celtic Era, without the Celtics would have been the height of that with Chamberlain, Robertson, Baylor and West, Pettit or later Barry dominating.

But the Celtics used Russell to change the game. His great talents were defense and rebounding. So the Celtics built their team around defense and then used their defense to ignite the offense on the fast break. They didn't care who scored- just hit the open man. Everybody scored 15-20 points per game. They scored more than anybody else and played the best defense in the league and basically just ran all those teams who were trying to get the ball to their star in the half court game right off the court.

Check out the team stats- and the winning percentage- on Basketball Reference.com:
http://www.basketball-reference.com/leagues/NBA_1957.html
Keep clicking on "next season" to go through Russell's career, which ended in 1969. He was only with the Celtics for the second half of the 1956-57 season as he was helping our Olympic team bring home the Gold in the Melbourne Olympics, which was played in November as that's summertime in the southern hemisphere.

Bill's teams won the California state high school championship in his junior and senior years. Freshmen were not eligible in college. In his sophomore year, San Francisco went 14-7. His junior and senior years they went 57-1 and won two national championships. Then he got the gold medal in Melbourne and joined the Celtics, who had never won anything and they won 11 NBA titles in 13 years. They didn't win in 1958 because Russell had injured his ankle and they were beaten by the 1967 Philadelphia 76ers, one of the greatest teams of all time, (they went 79-16, including the playoffs). They were supposed to displace the Celtics but Boston won the next two titles, the last over a Lakers team that had Chamberlain, Baylor and West, the ultimate attempt to overwhelm the Celtics with star players, which failed. The year after he retired, the Celtics went 34-48 without Russell, whose teams had won the ultimate championship they could have won 18 times in 21 seasons, (counting the Olympics as a 'season').

Bill Russell was the greatest winner in the history of teams sports and his teams won because of him.


(And I wasn't a Celtics fan,e either. I rooted for Wilt and the Sixers.)

Good summary. And they're a very big reason Tom Gola is not on the list in the OP. That and the fact he played defense and worked the boards, giving to his teams something similar to what Russell gave his. Just IMHO, that is ...
 
Lists like this are really hard because you are comparing people at different positions. I like Russell and think he was an amazing player but who would you put him above on the list? I think he is in the right spot.
 
How many ncaa teams were there? He won the title the two years in played college ball. Then won 11 of 13 nba titles. I was alive for those. it was no easy feat. the celts drafted last every year.
I'm younger than you and grew up watching the NBA starting with the 1969 Knicks and was a big Bill Bradley fan. I knew Bradley was a territorial selection so I assumed that Cousy and Heinsohn were territorial selections as well. It turns out that just Heinsohn was. Many people have no idea that there was such a thing as a territorial pick. I believe Bradley became a Knick because Princeton was one mile closer to NYC than Philadelphia.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NBA_territorial_pick

I also remember doing a book report on Bill Russell in maybe 5th grade. I'm not sure if my hatred of all things Boston sports had kicked in yet but knew enough at that time how great a player he was. I'm sure being a big star in Boston, who happened to be a somewhat outspoken black man, wasn't the easiest thing but he did become coach, and you would know this more than I would, and I assume the white fans embraced him. Not an easy thing in the turbulent 60's.
 
I'm younger than you and grew up watching the NBA starting with the 1969 Knicks and was a big Bill Bradley fan. I knew Bradley was a territorial selection so I assumed that Cousy and Heinsohn were territorial selections as well. It turns out that just Heinsohn was. Many people have no idea that there was such a thing as a territorial pick. I believe Bradley became a Knick because Princeton was one mile closer to NYC than Philadelphia.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NBA_territorial_pick

I also remember doing a book report on Bill Russell in maybe 5th grade. I'm not sure if my hatred of all things Boston sports had kicked in yet but knew enough at that time how great a player he was. I'm sure being a big star in Boston, who happened to be a somewhat outspoken black man, wasn't the easiest thing but he did become coach, and you would know this more than I would, and I assume the white fans embraced him. Not an easy thing in the turbulent 60's.
They embraced him as a player but they didn't want him living in their neighborhood. Russell had his new home trashed by racists.
 
Bill Russell might be the most overrated player of all time.

#hottake

This might be the dumbest post of all time.

All he did was fundamentally change the game. Before the Celtics obtained him in one of the most lopsided trades of all time (Easy Ed Macauley!?) the Celts were a good team. Never won a championship. Russell was with the Celts for 13 years. In 11 of those years, they won the championship. Sure the Celts had other good, even great players, Bob Cousy, the Jones "Brothers", Satch Sanders, "Ack Ack" Heinsohn. But I don't believe anybody who followed the NBA during that era would deny that Bill Russell was the key to the success of that dynasty. It's about winning. Not about stats. Bill Russell was a winner.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,411
Messages
4,890,217
Members
5,996
Latest member
meierscreek

Online statistics

Members online
267
Guests online
1,566
Total visitors
1,833


...
Top Bottom