Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Alsacs, post: 3112517, member: 652"] If he retired 2 years ago he would be a better candidate for the HOF. The HOF is the best place for the best of the best. The guy has gone 8-25 in his last 33 starts. QBs get the credit and the blame. Eli won 2 SBs those are the biggest part of his resume. Eli has no black ink on his NFL reference page except INTs 3 times. It is fine to acknowledge the guy has a great career but he was never one of the best at his position. Matthew Stafford has played 5 less years than Eli. If he plays those 5 years his numbers will pass Eli's. Eli is closer to Stafford than he is top the QBs of this generation. Stafford isn't a HOFer. [/QUOTE]