Not silly at all. I can take the emotion out of it. I can be an SU fan and still be realistic that McNabb won't ever sniff the HOF.
I was honest with my take on Harrison, he got screwed the past 2 years and should have been in 2 years ago. Coughlin is a HOF lock. Freeney probably gets in now that Kevin Greene is in and just has to wait on Jason Taylor to get in before he will. But McNabb is not HOF caliber. If you want to believe otherwise enjoy getting your hopes up every year and then being dissapointed the next 15 years when he doesn't get in.
I said this in another thread, Tc is def a lock, winning two sbs and taking an expansion team to two title games. I would put Freeney in, but I think its debatable, and he is going to have to wait. Mcnabb just didn't do enough to get in, very good qb, not a hof.