An 87 strikes me as being better than a 3 star.
Louis D’Agostino, D, Chaminade (N.Y.), LI Express Schreiber — Syracuse (3-star)
Evaluation Score: 87
D’Agostino brings LI toughness to his approach to cover defense. He does a strong job of sitting on hips playing body and bringing a physical brand of defense to the table. The lefty always has a stick in front and is working to maintain leverage. He slides hard and has no problem dropping a shoulder if that’s what the situation calls for. Otherwise, expect heavy checks deep in hands and then great footwork behind it.