Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="anomander, post: 1236818, member: 2766"] I don't really want to get into a debate or anything about this, and let me say I really respect your opinion and the insight you bring to the board, but I don't totally agree on this. I know there are mistakes, but for the most part I think the 4 and 5 stars are pretty accurate. 3 star and below is a total crapshoot just because there are so many. The reason I think they are pretty accurate is that most of the teams that get the 4 and 5 stars tend to be the top programs in the country, while teams like Syracuse who get mostly 3 and 2 stars are fighting to get to 6 wins every season. It seems like you are saying our recruiting has been better then the rankings? Then my question is why did we have 3 wins this season, and had to fight like hell to get to 6 last year? Sure their are outliers, but it's pretty accurate all the way down the line if you really look at them. I know i'd rather have a class ranked 25, then 50. [/QUOTE]