Player ratings, week 15

[moqui]

Every week, posters will be asked to rank the scholarship players in order, using whatever metric you want. Some will base it on total season production, some just on the most recent games, some on a combination, some on a metric of their own creation.

The only rules are that you must list at least 5 players, and you must list them in order - no ties. Force yourself to order them. I know it is hard; some weeks there will be very little difference between #3 and #7. If you do write "Player A and Player B tie" then I will rank Player A ahead because you wrote his name first.

There have been 2 games played since the last poll (Georgetown and Marquette). This poll will remain open until Friday.

There has been declining interest in the poll; if we continue to get fewer than 20 votes I think I will discontinue it.

Here are the Week 14 results:

my vote:

MCW
CJ
JS
BT
RC
BMK
JG
DC
TC

 

[arbitragegls]

1.Fair

2. Dirty
3.Triche
4.Keita
5. RAK
6. Cooney
7. MCW
8. Grant

 

[Texas Otto]

1 Fair
2 Southerland
3 Triche
4 Rak
5 Keita
6 Coleman
7 Grant
8 MCW
9 Cooney

 

[Orangello]

1 Fair
2 Southerland
3 Grant
4 Triche
5 MCW
6 Keita
7 Rak
8 Cooney
9 Coleman

 

[Upstate]

1. Fair
8.5. Keita
9. Southerland, Grant, Triche, MCW, Rak, Cooney, Coleman

 

[CuseinNYC]

Fair
MCW
Triche
Grant
Rak
JS
BMK
Cooney
DJC

Every week, posters will be asked to rank the scholarship players in order, using whatever metric you want. Some will base it on total season production, some just on the most recent games, some on a combination, some on a metric of their own creation.

The only rules are that you must list at least 5 players, and you must list them in order - no ties. Force yourself to order them. I know it is hard; some weeks there will be very little difference between #3 and #7. If you do write "Player A and Player B tie" then I will rank Player A ahead because you wrote his name first.

There have been 2 games played since the last poll (Georgetown and Marquette). This poll will remain open until Friday.

There has been declining interest in the poll; if we continue to get fewer than 20 votes I think I will discontinue it.

Here are the Week 14 results:

 

[Libero2]

C.J.
Southerland
Triche
MCW
Rak
Grant
Keita
Cooney
Coleman

 

[Gabjon]

1 Fair
2 Southerland
3 Keita
4 Grant
5 MCW
6 Triche
7 Cooney
8 Rak
9 Coleman

 

[ar inj]

1 Fair: best and most consistent - all conference


2 Triche: whether you like it or not, most important to success going forward
3 MCW: patience young one, patience
4 Southerland: some defense would help; movement on offense would be better
5 Keita active and tries his best, always

6 Grant rebounds and a little offense

7 Coleman need the big body and more Hulking
8 Christmas not the first center to make me think about dead men and rebounds
9 Cooney some signs of progress, maybe next year (a sweet sixteen game this year would be better)

 

[Melancer46]

1. Fair; pretty easy choice
2. MCW; actually liked the way he played against Georgetown for the most part, and he didn't do too bad last night.
3. Dirty
4. Triche
5. Christmas
6. Keita
7. Grant
8. Cooney
9. Coleman

 

[rrlbees]

Fair
Triche
MCW
Southerland
Keita
Rak
Grant
Cooney
Coleman


Sent using my Commodore 64

 

[Ghost]

1 Fair
2 Keita
3 Southerland
4 Rak
5 Grant
6 MCW
7 Triche
8 Cooney
9 Coleman

 

[IthacaMatt]

Every week, posters will be asked to rank the scholarship players in order, using whatever metric you want. Some will base it on total season production, some just on the most recent games, some on a combination, some on a metric of their own creation.

The only rules are that you must list at least 5 players, and you must list them in order - no ties. Force yourself to order them. I know it is hard; some weeks there will be very little difference between #3 and #7. If you do write "Player A and Player B tie" then I will rank Player A ahead because you wrote his name first.

There have been 2 games played since the last poll (Georgetown and Marquette). This poll will remain open until Friday.

There has been declining interest in the poll; if we continue to get fewer than 20 votes I think I will discontinue it.

Here are the Week 14 results:

Fair
Keita
Fair
Southerland
Fair
Christmas
Triche
Grant
MCW
Fair
Coleman
Cooney

Yes, Fair is 3 of our 5 best players, but also one of our 3 worst at the same time.

 

[tee1222]

1. CJ
2. Triche
3. MCW
4. JSouth
5. Rak
6. Grant
7. BMK
8. Cooney
9. DC2

 

[AirForceOrange]

Fair
Southerland
Triche
Christmas
Keita
Carter-Williams
Grant
Cooney
Coleman

 

[UnderHisOwnPower]

T H I C K B U R G E R
MCDub
James
Brandon
Don't worry...be Raky
Moose Man
SU Grant
TC
DaJuan

 

[br801]

1. Fair
2. Triche
3. MCW
4. Southy
5. Keita
6. Grant
7. Xmas
8. Cooney
9. DC2

 

[Madbiker]

1. CJ Fair
2. Southerland
3. MCW
4. Keita
5. Triche
6. Christmas
7. Cooney
8. Grant