I disagree with your comment:
1. Melo let down his team - anybody will be an upgrade. - You comparing past performance with prospective performance. To be better than the most recent team, he will have to perfom as well, or nearly as well as Melo did.
2. DC will be better than AO, though, of course if you are comparing DC as a frosh to AO as a senior, that isn't quite fair.
You compared this year's team to recent teams. To be better than that team, he will have to perfom as well, or nearly as well as AO did as a senior. The question was not who will be better as a senior. That's a different question.
3. CJ's game is different than KJOs, but he may well end up being just as good. Maybe, maybe not. KJ was a very, very good player his last 3 years.
4. Wes - agree, nobody in sight will be as good as Wes.
5. Andy - Cooney may well end up being close to an Andy clone if he can play good D. Really. This year Cooney will be a 2nd round NBA draft pick. Your supposition was that this team could be THE BEST in recent years. To do that, he would have to play like a JR. or Sr. Andy. I don't see that as a RS frosh., and I am a HUGE Cooney fan and think that people are wrong is thinking of him solely as a shooter. He is a good athlete, maybe better than Andy at the same point in time. Whether or not his is the player Andy was above the shoulders remains to be seen.
6. Dion - nobody has Dion's game, but MCW has a shot to be as good or better as a player & PG is a more important position than SG. Who says it's more important, especially in JB's system. ( I know that they are all time greats, but pick Jordan or BJ Armstrong, Kobe or Derek Fisher. Having great players is the most important, thing not their position. ) Plus, he would have to have a better year than Scoop. Not saying he isn't projected to be a better pro talent than Scoop, but Scoop had a really, really good year last year. Your prediction is based on a projection is that MCW will be play to a #4 pick level this year.
7. Depth - we haven't even added James, Brandon, X, and BMK to this conversation. We had all 4 guys last year. The only one I see being substanially better is X. ( I would note that I am not sold on James as a regular contibutor on a high level. I really hope that I am wrong about that.) +
I think this team will be very good, probably Top Ten good & any Top Ten team has a legit shot to make the FF if it gets some breaks and stays injury free.