rank em(?)

[Carl]

Pete Holihan
Greg Paulus
Joe G III

 

[NineOneSeven]

Y

 

[Lawrinson14]

based on what(?)

 

[Carl]

based on what(?)

good point-
1) basketball ability
2) QB

 

[ebucklewis]

Pete Holihan
Greg Paulus
Joe G III

Pete Holihan was a 12 year pro at the highest level.
I don’t expect the other 2 to achieve that. I don’t know how else to rank them.

 

[Carl]

Pete Holihan was a 12 year pro at the highest level.
I don’t expect the other 2 to achieve that. I don’t know how else to rank them.

also a fair point- how about comparing them as High school seniors then?

 

[alphaorange]

Holihan was a tight end, not a QB...was he not?

 

[ebucklewis]

Holihan was a tight end, not a QB...was he not?

Yes. In the NFL. Little on the slow side (for NFL) but had fantastic hands.

 

[Carl]

Holihan was a tight end, not a QB...was he not?

ND converted him

 

[SWC75]

No idea about Holohan, (mid 70's) but I beleive Paulus was higher rated than Girard in both sports:

Joseph Girard, Glens Falls Senior, Combo Guard

Joseph Girard, Glens Falls Senior, Pro-Style Quarterback

Greg Paulus - Wikipedia

 

[OrlandoCuse]

Ranked alphabetically:

1) Girard
2) Holohan
3) Paulus

#done

 

[OrlandoCuse]

Ranked youngest to oldest

1) Girard
2) Paulus
3) Holohan

#done

 

[OrlandoCuse]

Ranked Eastern most to West:

1) Girard
2) Paulus
3) Holohan

#done

 

[dollarbill44]

Pete Holihan
Greg Paulus
Joe G III

What, no love for Dave Lemanczyk?

[Edit] just saw that you were looking for QBs. Not sure if he was one in HS.