Rank the following wide receivers...

[Eric15]

All other things being equal, if you had to win 1 game, in what order would you take the following four receivers in their prime?

Calvin Johnson
Randy Moss
Terrell Owens
Jerry Rice

 

[JJReddawg]

Jerry Rice
Randy Moss
Calvin Johnson
TO

 

[SWFLCUSE]

Jerry Rice
Randy Moss
Calvin Johnson
TO

For now I agree with this, but when its all said and done I think it will go
Rice
Johnson
Moss
TO

 

[cliftonparksufan]

All other things being equal, if you had to win 1 game, in what order would you take the following four receivers in their prime?

Calvin Johnson
Randy Moss
Terrell Owens
Jerry Rice

I'm still of the belief that Rice gets his own category. I agree that CJ could end up two.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2

 

[swish7]

All other things being equal, if you had to win 1 game, in what order would you take the following four receivers in their prime?

Calvin Johnson
Randy Moss
Terrell Owens
Jerry Rice

Jerry Rice
Terrell Owens
Randy Moss
Calvin Johnson

 

[cuseincincy]

Jerry Rice
Randy Moss
Calvin Johnson
TO

Agreed.

 

[Trueblue25]

Kobena
West
Clarke
Tajh Smith
Rice
Moss
TO
Johnson

 

[cusefan88]

Rice at age 40 playing for Oakland in 2002. 92 rec 1211 7 TD. wow

 

[jekelish]

Rice, Megatron, Moss


TO is not worth ranking.

 

[kirbivore]

Moss isn't worth ranking. never won a damn thing

 

[sufandu]

Rice (duh)
TO (I think he's horrible for a team, but for one game he proved he could be a stud)
Megatron (He's better than TO but he hasn't done it in a big game yet)
Moss (Do we have other guys I can put in front of him? All I think of with Moss is alligator arms. I give no respect to a guy that only wants to catch the deep ball and is afraid to go over the middle)

 

[jekelish]

By the way, if we are talking about WRs in their primes, I would take Marvin Harrison over TO or Moss.

 

[Eric15]

Moss isn't worth ranking. never won a damn thing

Does that mean Dan Marino isn't worth ranking amongst all-time QBs, or Stockton/Malone amongst NBA greats?

 

[4evaOrange]

Take Owens out and put Irvin in, does that change any list?

 

[sufandu]

Take Owens out and put Irvin in, does that change any list?

Are we calling offensive pass interference?

 

[Millhouse]

All other things being equal, if you had to win 1 game, in what order would you take the following four receivers in their prime?

Calvin Johnson
Randy Moss
Terrell Owens
Jerry Rice

Rice
Johnson
Moss
Rice moss
Jerry Butler
Chris Burkett
Roland Hooks
TO

 

[Eric15]

Take Owens out and put Irvin in, does that change any list?

Just my personal opinion (this is outside of the 1-game in their prime question)... I think Michael Irvin is slightly overrated. He was a great WR, no doubt, but he's tied for 46th all-time in career touchdown receptions.

 

[CusefanATL]

Jerry Rice
Calvin Johnson
Marvin Harrison (seriously? no one had him on their list in the top 4?)
Moss
TO

 

[sufandu]

Jerry Rice
Calvin Johnson
Marvin Harrison (seriously? no one had him on their list in the top 4?)
Moss
TO

People didn't have him in their list because we were ranking the list of 4 given to us in the OP.

 

[Eric15]

Jerry Rice
Calvin Johnson
Marvin Harrison (seriously? no one had him on their list in the top 4?)
Moss
TO

Harrison is clearly an all-time great, but if I need one guy for one game, I think he'd be more in 6-10 range. I don't think he has the physical tools of Rice, Moss, TO and Calvin Johnson.

If I needed someone shot he'd be first.

 

[CusefanATL]

People didn't have him in their list because we were ranking the list of 4 given to us in the OP.

a lot of people expanded... including jekelish who i missed and brought up harrison.

 

[Timonen]

Kobena
West
Clarke
Tajh Smith
Rice
Moss
TO
Johnson

Love how you worked Rice Moss in there subtlety.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Bobby Johnson
Lionel Manuel
Stephen Baker the Touchdown Maker
Mark Ingram
Stacey Robinson
Earnest Gray
John Mistler

whoops sorry, i thought we were showing the soup pusher fans how you can win with crappy WRs...

Moss: in his absolute prime, he was doing things Rice couldnt do
Rice
Calvin

TO was very good, but i wouldnt put him in this class.

 

[4evaOrange]

Rank the Tight Ends. Off the top of my head, Tony G, Jason Witten. Who else goes in this list??

 

[CusefanATL]

Harrison is clearly an all-time great, but if I need one guy for one game, I think he'd be more in 6-10 range. I don't think he has the physical tools of Rice, Moss, TO and Calvin Johnson.

If I needed someone shot he'd be first.

i dont know... irvin probably had really good connnections for that.
chris henry (rip)
obviously rae carruth
seeing that jimmy graham is going to petition the nfl for wr eligibility for his franchise contract... ill also put what would be an obvious #1... aaron hernandez