I think that moves Bobby in front of Rob Moore in terms of recruits landed. Looks like he is going to turn an area of major weakness into an area of strength...
I feel like I'm being disrespectful of Moore by agreeing but I do agree.
I think that moves Bobby in front of Rob Moore in terms of recruits landed. Looks like he is going to turn an area of major weakness into an area of strength...
Of our two commitments Fredericksburg is in my opinion definitely the faster of the two and more of a true running back. Perkins may be more of a McFarlane type, in that put him where he can most help the team based on his skills and position need. Remember McFarlane was switched to D before going back to TB.I could definitely see Fredericks moving to defense, maybe thats why. Like a Doug Hogue type.
I agree with your premise and hope that we can attain that position with NYS kids. Problem with your example, however, is that Cabinda in from New Jersey ;-)Penn State to Pennsylvania kids is most times the gold standard offer, ie Jason Cabinda last year. Perhaps our beloved CUSE will (is) develop something similar in NY State/NYC. The right coaches, the ACC and a new winning program will get us there!
They're from NY so they must not be very good. They aren't rated highly by the recruiting services so they can't be good. What is the staff doing? They should be in New Jersey where all the players are good.Just how good are these 2 new RB's? Weren't there other more highly sought on our list? Maybe we take a 3rd? Just seems strange we get 2 RB's before anything else and they may not even be the best in NYS.
I just watched the Fredericks' tape.
He runs much like Terrell Hunt or Jerome Smith- Not particularly fast, not overwhelmingly powerful, but quite skilled at finding space and getting extra yards.
I disagree with you about Smith LC, I never thought he had good vision or feel for holes. Hunt yes.
They're from NY so they must not be very good. They aren't rated highly by the recruiting services so they can't be good. What is the staff doing? They should be in New Jersey where all the players are good.
Terrell Hunt or Jerome Smith? He's much faster than both if those guys not to mention Smith and Hunt don't have similar styles.I just watched the Fredericks' tape.
He runs much like Terrell Hunt or Jerome Smith- Not particularly fast, not overwhelmingly powerful, but quite skilled at finding space and getting extra yards.
Strange post
Terrell Hunt or Jerome Smith? He's much faster than both if those guys not to mention Smith and Hunt don't have similar styles.
The point is that people on this Board have a natural tendency to disrespect NYS players. There's an assumption if they don't have multiple offers that means they aren't good. I will use Nick Robinson as an example. In a thread on the football board people weren't even including him in the discussion of who's going start at guard this year even though he started and excelled last year. He's from Bville and only had one BCS offer and I think a lot of people look down on him. If he we're from Florida and had multiple offers he wound be much more respected.Strange post
they may not even be the best in NYS.
Yes I did watch it and yes I did see him runnig away from people.Did you watch the same video I did? He's not running away from anybody.
The point is that people on this Board have a natural tendency to disrespect NYS players. There's an assumption if they don't have multiple offers that means they aren't good. I will use Nick Robinson as an example. In a thread on the football board people weren't even including him in the discussion of who's going start at guard this year even though he started and excelled last year. He's from Bville and only had one BCS offer and I think a lot of people look down on him. If he we're from Florida and had multiple offers he wound be much more respected.
I feel you're disrespecting this kid in the same sort of way. Watch his film, he's fast and has good vision. He looks as good as any of the backs I have seen recently.
To support my point Lemoyne just compared him to Terrel Hunt! I believe it's because he's from New York. IMO this is grossly under recruited state and the players are grossly under valued.
The staff is damned if they do and damned if they don't when it comes to NYS kids as far as this fanbase is concerned. I think that alot of familiar posters still have some lingering hurt we didn't bring in local NYS RB T. Rouse last year and now question these commits at a similiar position of need. Last year, the moaning that went on about us expanding our recruiting base to the mid-west and not moreso in NYS and the NE was epic. Now, we get NYS under-the-radar kids high on our board and the moaning continues.
Based upon what i have read, both of these players are D-1 caliber athletes. In NYS, due to lack of overall talent, most of the time your best athletes will play QB or RB on offense. That doesn't mean they will play the same position in college. Bring in program guys and athletes who can play football and the positional battle will work itself out.
Further, we aren't done at RB and some of the out of state guys everyone desires are still on the board and we will bring in another guy or two that can compete at the position.
Strange post
I assume it was laced with sarcasm.
In NYS, due to lack of overall talent, most of the time your best athletes will play QB or RB on offense. That doesn't mean they will play the same position in college. Bring in program guys and athletes who can play football and the positional battle will work itself out.
Of our two commitments Fredericksburg is in my opinion definitely the faster of the two and more of a true running back. Perkins may be more of a McFarlane type, in that put him where he can most help the team based on his skills and position need. Remember McFarlane was switched to D before going back to TB.
The point is that people on this Board have a natural tendency to disrespect NYS players. There's an assumption if they don't have multiple offers that means they aren't good. I will use Nick Robinson as an example. In a thread on the football board people weren't even including him in the discussion of who's going start at guard this year even though he started and excelled last year. He's from Bville and only had one BCS offer and I think a lot of people look down on him. If he we're from Florida and had multiple offers he wound be much more respected.
I feel you're disrespecting this kid in the same sort of way. Watch his film, he's fast and has good vision. He looks as good as any of the backs I have seen recently.
To support my point Lemoyne just compared him to Terrel Hunt! I believe it's because he's from New York. IMO this is grossly under recruited state and the players are grossly under valued.
Well first, I am a big supporter of the 6 hour rule, so that includes NYS. My point was that these are our first 2 commits and they are both NYS RB's. I know we have a couple higher up on the board, thus this isn't the end for RB unless others all say no to us.
AmenThe staff is damned if they do and damned if they don't when it comes to NYS kids as far as this fanbase is concerned. I think that alot of familiar posters still have some lingering hurt we didn't bring in local NYS RB T. Rouse last year and now question these commits at a similiar position of need. Last year, the moaning that went on about us expanding our recruiting base to the mid-west and not moreso in NYS and the NE was epic. Now, we get NYS under-the-radar kids high on our board and the moaning continues.
SUFan44 said:Who says they're going to stay at RB?