THE BUILD-UP
Much of the talk early in the week was about how great the Colgate game had been. Jack Slattery of the Herald-Journal felt that it was time to pay tribute to both teams:
“Before the football season started Syracuse was selected by the experts, (there are other names for them but I’ll stick to the word ‘expert’), to win one game. They won one- and then some. If they had had a game under their belt when they played Pittsburgh I honestly believe they would have been able to defeat the Panthers. And if they weren’t somewhat awe-stricken, I think they would have scared the daylights out of Maryland. (But not lick them.) And I believe they should have defeated Penn State.”
“Which brings us up to the Colgate game. I think the Red Raiders should have been defeated by three touchdowns. But they weren’t and not because of anything the Orange didn’t do. It was what the Raiders did. There is just one word to describe the Raider team on Saturday- magnificent. They were a superb team. Fired up and hard hitting as any team can be. Well coached and inspired. Syracuse coach Ben Schwartzwalder called them “a great team”. He said Syracuse worked as hard to get the winning touchdown as it had worked all year. “
But Slattery was disappointed in the attitude in the Colgate locker room after the game: “I honestly mean it when I say that the visit to the Colgate locker room after the game spoiled the afternoon for me. The game itself was splendid. The loyalest of Colgate rooters, dejected in defeat, admitted that it was a wonderful ball game and that the Raiders had played their hearts out against a team superior to them. But to go into the dressing room and listen to youngsters sob and hear the coaches hand out abuse for the officials took all the joy out of the occasion.”
Slattery blamed it, not on the coaches themselves but on the pressure put on them by the alumni to win, especially in “rivalry” series like Syracuse-Colgate. “When a man spends thousands of dollars to send his son to college he hopes to have his boy influenced by the likes of a man like Hal Lahar. But when the alumni pressure to win one ball game becomes so great that it makes a man say things he now wished he’d never said it is time that the people who give out diplomas start taking a few back. “
Bill Reddy noted that Lahar claimed to have warned the officials before the game that “Syracuse holds all over the field.” Reddy said that “If he did that, he was taking an action which is not supposed to be permitted in intercollegiate football. No such pre game warnings are allowed under the collegiate code of ethics and, if the officials allowed such advance chatter they should be censured by the eastern commissioner, Asa Bushnell. The basis for such a complaint is hard to find…Observers at last week’s Penn State-Syracuse game thought the Orange got the worst of the officiating but it wasn’t permitted to become a sore point….Here is a fact which may seem unbelievable but it’s in the records. In six of Syracuse’s seven games, the Orange was not penalized once for illegal use of hands, which, of course, includes holding. Thus 24 different officials watched Syracuse in six games and didn’t assess a single holding penalty.”
Lahar for his part, issued this statement: “Evidently I have already done too much talking about the officials. No one man is big enough to cause a Syracuse-Colgate breach. I have a great deal of respect for Orange football. I’ve never been an official baiter but felt than an infraction should have been seen…I thought our kids deserved a tie and I was sore because they didn’t get it. ” No one man would end the Syracuse-Colgate series. But from here on the superiority of the Orange teams would make the end of our greatest rivalry inevitable.
The final opponent of the 1955 season was still another formidable one. West Virginia, under Art “Pappy” Lewis, (who had been the youngest head coach in NFL history when he coached the Cleveland Rams at age 27 in 1939), the Mountaineers had had quite a run. Lewis took over the program, which did not have sterling history in the sport. His first team went 2-8, his second 5-5 but his third broke through to 7-2 and they finished second in the then huge Southern Conference, which was about to give birth to the ACC. With the foundation of that conference in 1953, the ‘Neers dominated the SC, stretching their winning streak to 13 games before being upset by South Carolina of the ACC, 14-20. They finished 8-1 and were invited to the Sugar Bowl to play Georgia Tech, at that time a major national power under Coach Bobby Dodd. Just as Syracuse was not ready for Alabama the previous year, West Virginia was not ready for Georgia Tech, losing 19-42 in a game that wasn’t that close.
http://www.allstatesugarbowl.org/site147.php
They came back just as strong the next year, again going 8-1. The two frustrations were that the one loss was to arch-rival Pittsburgh by only 3 points, 10-13 and, after the poor showing against the Yellow Jackets, they got no bowl invitation, (which tells us what would have happened to the 1953 Orangemen if they’d won their tie game and their three losses by a total of 14 points: they weren’t going where after the Alabama disaster no matter what they did).
The Mounties had another strong team in 1955, winning their first seven games, including a third straight victory over Penn State. They then had a chance for revenge against Pittsburgh. But it just wasn’t heir day and Pitt rolled to a 26-0 lead. West Virginia scored on the game’s last play but the Pitt fans, (like the SU fans vs. Colgate), had destroyed the goal posts so no conversion could be attempted. They could have run a play for it but instead, the Pitt coaching staff was gracious enough to concede the extra point, probably the only point in football history that was not the product of a play. Still, they were a strong 7-1 going into the Syracuse game and were 29-4 in their last 33 games. And the game was scheduled to be played in Morgantown. Ben Schwartzwalder said he was going back to West Virginia, where he had played “with reluctance because I know we’re in for trouble in Saturday’s game”.
One of the reasons they might be in trouble was that starting Quarterback Eddie Albright was questionable for the game. He had been hurt in a pile-up in the Colgate game, so badly they were taking him off the field on a stretcher. But he got up from the stretcher and insisted on leaving under his own power. Fortunately, Syracuse had depth and it was argued that their greater depth, and Schwartzwalder’s use of it in rotating his players, enabled them to outlast the Red Raiders and put on that long grinding drive, that won the game. X-rays were negative but Albright still had “back and hip bruises”. Then it was revealed that back-up quarterback Ferdie, (aka Fred) Kuzala was also injured, having hurt his shoulder in the Colgate game. Even the third string quarterback, Lou Iannicello, “was not at his best”. Nonetheless Schwartzwalder stated that he had plans to throw the ball more vs. West Virginia, due to the size of West Virginia’s line, (220 pounds per man, 15 more than Syracuse’s). But who would do the throwing?
Rocky Pirro had scouted the Mountaineers vs. Pitt and said that a key play came when West Virginia quarterback Fred Wyant was clipped and injured his knee. He came back in the game but couldn’t run an option play with the required speed, got hit and fumbled, leading to a Pittsburgh score. Wyant missed most of the second half. Arnie Burdick asked Pappy Lewis about this in a phone news conference and Lewis insisted that Wyant was fine and would be ready for the Syracuse game. He claimed Wyant had a “bumped shin”. Pirro noted that it wasn’t his shin that was wrapped up when he came back in. Schwartzwalder picked up on this and referred to all of his injured players as having “bumped shins”. On Saturday it was revealed that Wyant had torn ligaments and would miss the game, being replaced by his back-up, Mickey Trimarki.
Lewis claimed that his team was better than the Sugar Bowl team and attributed this to his two splendid 225 pound tackles, Bruce Bosley, (who played for the 49ers for 13 years) and Sam Huff, (future New York Giant legend). Pirro agreed: “Maryland didn’t have a lineman on its team that can play with either of those fellows.” That included Bob Pellegrini, the Terp’s All-American tackle. The paper had a picture of Huff yelling at the camera in a posed shot. Unfortunately guard Chuck Howley, (later a linebacker for the Cowboys for 13 years), had a sprained ankle).
Lewis was concerned about his team fumbling too much. They’d lost four in a narrow 13-7 over Gorge Washington and three more vs. Pitt. They were running some anti-fumbling drills. They’d also “passed too much”, completing only 4 of 23 against the Panthers.
The Mountaineers had the nation’s most productive offense with 407 yards per game. They had the sixth best rushing attack with 266 yards per game and the seventh best passing attack with 142 yards per game. 194lb Bob Moss was the 9th most prolific runner in the country with 598 yards, (Jim Brown was #14 with 550 but had played one less game: his average per game was better with 79 vs. 75). 218lb Fullback Joe Marconi seemed to have a bright future. Behind them was the team’s fastest player, Vic “Jack” Rabbits, who was behind Moss and Marconi only because of his size, (162 pounds). Rabbitts was averaging an incredible 9.3 yards per carry on only 38 attempts. Included in his total was a 99 yard TD scamper vs. VMI. He was also averaging 50 yards a punt return- on two returns, both for scores.
“Lewis had been quoted last week as favoring an eastern independent conference, long a cherished project in the area and he was asked about that idea again. “I sure wish there was an eastern independent conference and I’d like to see our team in it.” Asked what teams he’d like to see in an eastern independent conference besides West Virginia, Lewis named Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Colgate and added “a couple of others to round it out.” Another article said that Miami and Houston were being considered for admission into the SEC.
A picture in Wednesday’s Post Standard showed two Syracuse University players, in full uniform, being sworn in to the Army Reserves by Lt. Colonel Ben Schwartzwalder, in his coach’s outfit. The players are Jim Ridlon and Joe Rose. The next day there was a small article about former Orangeman Avatus Stone being named MVP of the CFL. He was playing for the Ottawa Rough Riders.
Bill Reddy complained, “We’ve reached the ‘traditional rivalry’ stage in college football and we’ve also reached the stage in which teams like Syracuse and West Virginia which have played only twice before are ending a season with no trophy, no jug and no beanpot at stake.” Lirtle did he know that the teams would be playing for the next 58 years in row and that someday they would be playing for the “Schwartzwalder Trophy”. He said there had been a lot of discussion over whether the Mountaineers would be ‘up’ or ‘down’ after their disappointing performance against Pittsburgh and whether either team would be ‘up’ after playing their big rival. “So which team is likely to be ‘up’? It’s only in the ‘big ones’ that you can be fairly certain that both of them will be ‘up’. I’ll be surprised if Syracuse wins this one. It will be a pleasant surprise to be sure but I’m not going to Morgantown expecting to see a victory.”
Tuesday’s paper had an article outlining the increased popularity of Orange football, based on attendance figures. It had number for the previous four years, (more specific than listed in the current SU Media Guide). The 1952 SU team totaled 125,519 paid attendance for 6 whole games, an average of 20,920. The 1953 team played for home games and drew 94,616, an average of 23,654. In 1954 it was 90,889/22,722.25. In 1955 attendance grew to 105,946, an average of 26,487 per game. The Pittsburgh game had drawn only 16,896 but it was on TV. The Boston U. game was 17,176 but the opponent wasn’t all that attractive. The Maryland game was 32,410 against one of the top teams in the country. The Colgate game had set an all-time Archbold Stadium record with 39,464. In addition, on the road, Syracuse had sold out the Army game, (which only drew 10,000 in actual attendance due to the horrible weather), the Holy Cross and the Penn State game. 22,000 were expected in Morgantown for the West Virginia game. Syracuse was becoming “New York State’s College Team”. The TV money was also beginning to come in, $15,000 for the Pittsburgh game and $10,000 from the Penn State game. The attendance and dollar numbers in those days would be considered pitiful now but they were big news in 1955.
It was the first time Schwartzwalder would face his alma mater as a coach and the first time Syracuse played them since 1946, when the Orange had lost in Morgantown, 0-13 after winning the previous year in Archbold, 12-0, the only two prior games in the series. Little did anyone know that the two schools would play each other each year for the next 58 seasons. (And it’s a shame that the Mountaineers aren’t going to join us in the ACC, where they could be re-united with not only their old Big East rivals but also their ancient Southern Conference foes who left to form the ACC back in the day). Syracuse would be flying to this game- sort of. They’d fly to Pittsburgh and then take a bus to Morgantown. It was “Mountaineer Day”. Male students had been growing beards and would be given coonskin caps to wear at the game. “Coeds will be in feminine Mountaineer attire”. Whatever that was.
http://superitch.com/images/2010/02/daisymae.jpg
Oscar Fraley, (later the author of “The Untouchables”) had a column in the Herald-Journal predicting games and figured West Virginia would win this game in “The big bounce back”. Will Grimsley had a similar column in the Post Standard and also picked West Virginia, (he used a specific score: 14-21), for the same reason. That was the consensus of the oddsmakers- West Virginia was a 7 point favorite. The entire officiating crew would be provided by the Southern Conference, adding to the concern.
But someone had other ideas. A letter was sent to Lewis sating “Art: This is to warn you that unless you want something terrible to happen to you and your team don’t beat Syracuse next Saturday. This is not a ‘crank’ letter and we are well enough organized to make you feel very sorry if you fail to heed our warning. DON’T CRY TO CROSS US PAPPY AS WE WILL HAVE SOMEONE THERE WATCHING EVERYTHING.” The letter was mailed from Newark New Jersey. (Coach Bill Murray of Duke got a similar letter, also from Newark, about his game with Wake Forest.) Lewis’ comment: They sure picked a fine day. Everyone in the stands will be toting rifles with it being Mountaineer day.”