Who do you have Manny or Floyd

[victor]

My heart is with Manny but my head says Floyd will win and that Manny is past his prime. Hopefully I am wrong.

 

[djcon57]

Floyd by easy decision

 

[SWC75]

1) Great boxers over great punchers
2) As you can see when they pose together, Mayweather is the naturally larger man. He started as a junior lightweight and grew into a welterweight. Pacquiao started a sa flyweight and built himself into a welterweight. There's a difference.
3) Pacquiao is a year younger but is the older fighter, having taken punches to deliver them. Mayweather makes his man miss and counters. Manny gained fans as an action fighter but he's been through too many wars. Mayweather hs avoided the wars.
4) Manny's baeen beaten five times and drawn twice. Marquez, who Mayweather easily beat, had one draw and almost killed Manny when they last fought. nobody's beaten Mayweather.

 

[victor]

1) Great boxers over great punchers
2) As you can see when they pose together, Mayweather is the naturally larger man. He started as a junior lightweight and grew into a welterweight. Pacquiao started a sa flyweight and built himself into a welterweight. There's a difference.
3) Pacquiao is a year young but is the older fighter, having taken punches to deliver them. Mayweather makes his man miss and counters. Manny gained fans as an action fighter but he's been through to many wars. Mayweather ahs avoided the wars.
4) Manny's been beaten five times and drawn twice. Marquez, who Mayweather easily beat, had one draw and almost killed Manny when they last fought. nobody's beaten Mayweather.

Can't argue with your assessment. Would have love to have seen how Floyd would have done against a natural welter weight like Sugar Ray Leonard or Tommy Hearns.

 

[Shawn91111]

Floyd by easy decision

Same, just great defense