A fatigued Mike Williams(2-star) was alot better than a rested Lobdell(4-star). FWIW, I just read another article about the flawed star-system. It showed that something like 5 of Bama's recruits this year got instant star 'bumps' after committing to Bama. There was no further evaluation, nothing expect a verbal to a factory. It went into detail about how these rating services stay alive through the relationships they have with certain factories and their donors. They don't want to be caught giving the illusion that one of these moneymakers is having a bad recruiting season as that could potentially lead to a bad financial season for the rating service.