2022 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot | Syracusefan.com

2022 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot

Debuting on the BBWAA ballot in 2022 are
  • Carl Crawford
  • Prince Fielder
  • Ryan Howard
  • Tim Lincecum
  • Justin Morneau
  • Joe Nathan
  • David Ortiz
  • Jonathan Papelbon
  • Jake Peavy
  • A.J. Pierzynski
  • Álex Rodríguez
  • Jimmy Rollin
  • Mark Teixeira

Seventeen former players are returning to the 2022 BBWAA ballot after receiving at least five percent of the overall vote in 2021:

  • Curt Schilling
    71.1%
    10th year
  • Barry Bonds
    61.8%
    10th year
  • Roger Clemens
    61.6%
    10th year
  • Scott Rolen
    52.9%
    5th year
  • Omar Vizquel
    49.1%
    5th year
  • Billy Wagner
    46.4%
    7th year
  • Todd Helton
    44.9%
    4th year
  • Gary Sheffield
    40.6%
    8th year
  • Andruw Jones
    33.9%
    5th year
  • Jeff Kent
    32.4%
    9th year
  • Manny Ramírez
    28.2%
    6th year
  • Sammy Sosa
    17.0%
    10th year
  • Andy Pettitte
    13.7%
    4th year
  • Mark Buehrle
    11.0%
    2nd year
  • Torii Hunter
    9.5%
    2nd year
  • Bobby Abreu
    8.7%
    3rd year
  • Tim Hudson
    5.2%
    2nd year
 
This is going to be a very interesting year for the voters

None of the first year players are guaranteed to get into the HOF. Obviously Ortiz and A-Rod have the stats, but question marks with PEDs. Then the voters have to make the final call on Bonds/Clemens before they roll off the ballot. Then finally Schilling who is quite close to getting over the hump

As a Yankees fan, I have nightmares of a Schilling/Ortiz/Papelbon HOF class, as unrealistic as that may be in real life.

My guess is Schilling finally makes it and the writers will punt the PED era to the veterans committee.
 
Interesting to think what Prince Fielder's numbers would have ended up wtihout retiring early with neck problems.
 
KaiserUEO said:
This makes me extremely happy.

Tommy John should be next.

But let’s not forget the one man who has continuously been screwed over….Thurman “The Captain” Munson.
Expand...
Yes, not enough statistics for Munson unfortunately and he was my favorite player. I saw him at an auto show in Syracuse in probably 1975 or 76, he signed my scrapbook with all of his newspaper clippings. I remember he had snake skin or alligator skin boots on. He could not have been kinder to me, a young girl that loved baseball.
 
OrangeXtreme said:
Debuting on the BBWAA ballot in 2022 are
  • Carl Crawford
  • Prince Fielder
  • Ryan Howard
  • Tim Lincecum
  • Justin Morneau
  • Joe Nathan
  • David Ortiz
  • Jonathan Papelbon
  • Jake Peavy
  • A.J. Pierzynski
  • Álex Rodríguez
  • Jimmy Rollin
  • Mark Teixeira

Seventeen former players are returning to the 2022 BBWAA ballot after receiving at least five percent of the overall vote in 2021:

  • Curt Schilling
    71.1%
    10th year
  • Barry Bonds
    61.8%
    10th year
  • Roger Clemens
    61.6%
    10th year
  • Scott Rolen
    52.9%
    5th year
  • Omar Vizquel
    49.1%
    5th year
  • Billy Wagner
    46.4%
    7th year
  • Todd Helton
    44.9%
    4th year
  • Gary Sheffield
    40.6%
    8th year
  • Andruw Jones
    33.9%
    5th year
  • Jeff Kent
    32.4%
    9th year
  • Manny Ramírez
    28.2%
    6th year
  • Sammy Sosa
    17.0%
    10th year
  • Andy Pettitte
    13.7%
    4th year
  • Mark Buehrle
    11.0%
    2nd year
  • Torii Hunter
    9.5%
    2nd year
  • Bobby Abreu
    8.7%
    3rd year
  • Tim Hudson
    5.2%
    2nd year
Expand...

Just based on a "gut test" - thinking about whether guys were considered the best of their era, regardless of the steroids, speed or other enhancing drugs players have taken over time - I consider these guys Hall of Famers:

Alex Rodriguez
David Ortiz
Jonathan Pappelbon

Barry Bonds
Roger Clemens
Manny Ramirez

Andy Pettitte would be marginal based on his regular season record, but had a great post-season record and won multiple titles. If that gets Phil Rizzuto into the Hall, it should probably get in Pettitte. Andy also ate up innings like a workhorse from the 1970s or 1980s.
 
IthacaMatt said:
Just based on a "gut test" - thinking about whether guys were considered the best of their era, regardless of the steroids, speed or other enhancing drugs players have taken over time - I consider these guys Hall of Famers:

Alex Rodriguez
David Ortiz
Jonathan Pappelbon

Barry Bonds
Roger Clemens
Manny Ramirez

Andy Pettitte would be marginal based on his regular season record, but had a great post-season record and won multiple titles. If that gets Phil Rizzuto into the Hall, it should probably get in Pettitte. Andy also ate up innings like a workhorse from the 1970s or 1980s.
Expand...
Pettitte has 100+ more wins than losses, but the anti-Yankee bias will be used against him for years.

Paplelbum is not a HOFer.
 
NineOneSeven said:
Absolutely laughable Barry Bonds isn’t in the hall of fame. At age 39 he had an OBP of over 0.600.

0.600!!!

A statistic that will never be topped. Ever. Not even close.
Expand...
Well he only has himself to blame. He will get in but hes going to wait.
 
KaiserUEO said:
This makes me extremely happy.

Tommy John should be next.

But let’s not forget the one man who has continuously been screwed over….Thurman “The Captain” Munson.
Expand...
His biggest claim is that he was a Yankee. Grit and a tragic death isn’t enough.
The thing I will always remember are his last 2 at bats: flew out and ground in.
 
KaiserUEO said:
Pettitte has 100+ more wins than losses, but the anti-Yankee bias will be used against him for years.

Paplelbum is not a HOFer.
Expand...
Petite is PED tainted and a product of his team.
 
KaiserUEO said:
So is Ortiz and Manny…to a far worse degree.

And your put down of Thurman is quite embarrassing, id delete it.
Expand...
Arias is getting in you and you will be pissed.

Schilling is a HOF but I am okay with making him wait for veterans committee.

The BBWAA sucks though and I wish the HOF voting has accountability.

Like the guy who has voted for nobody but Mariano Rivera in the last 5 years.

If you submit 2 blank ballots in a row you gotta lose your vote.
 
Alsacs said:
Arias is getting in you and you will be pissed.

Schilling is a HOF but I am okay with making him wait for veterans committee.

The BBWAA sucks though and I wish the HOF voting has accountability.

Like the guy who has voted for nobody but Mariano Rivera in the last 5 years.

If you submit 2 blank ballots in a row you gotta lose your vote.
Expand...
Oh, I have a to of problems with the BBWA for sure, many posted on here.

Schilling is a HOFer.
 
Because you guys love it, here are their career WARs from FanGraphs:

Bonds 164.4
Clemens 133.7
Rodriguez 113.7
Schilling 79.8
Rolen 69.9
Pettitte 68.2
Jones 67.0
Ramirez 66.3
Sheffield 62.1
Sosa 60.1
Abreu 59.8
Kent 56.0
Helton 54.9
Buehrle 52.3
Ortiz 51.0
Rollins 49.4
Hudson 48.9
Teixeira 44.8
Peavy 43.7
Hunter 43.0
Vizquel 42.5
Crawford 41.5
Fielder 27.5
Lincecum 27.5
Wagner 24.0
Morneau 22.7
Pierzynski 20.7
Howard 19.6
Nathan 19.5
Papelbon 19.4
 
donniesyracuse said:
Because you guys love it, here are their career WARs from FanGraphs:

Bonds 164.4
Clemens 133.7
Rodriguez 113.7
Schilling 79.8
Rolen 69.9
Pettitte 68.2
Jones 67.0
Ramirez 66.3
Sheffield 62.1
Sosa 60.1
Abreu 59.8
Kent 56.0
Helton 54.9
Buehrle 52.3
Ortiz 51.0
Rollins 49.4
Hudson 48.9
Teixeira 44.8
Peavy 43.7
Hunter 43.0
Vizquel 42.5
Crawford 41.5
Fielder 27.5
Lincecum 27.5
Wagner 24.0
Morneau 22.7
Pierzynski 20.7
Howard 19.6
Nathan 19.5
Papelbon 19.4
Expand...

The top 3 guys on that list - the only ones who are plus-100 - all belong in the Hall.
 
Do Arias or Bonds get in tomorrow?

Both are close. Ortiz seems like he will more likely.
 
my guy Barry isn't getting in. Sad. It's a museum.

Laughable... and i mean LAUGHABLE... that Bud Selig is in the HOF, but Bonds and Clemens won't be. Then again, it's the MLB... they don't do much right
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

cayugacuse
    • Like
Gary Anderson HOF Nominee
Replies
3
Views
473
OrangeAl
OrangeAl
CuseLegacy
    • Like
Class of 2027 WR Damari Hall (CA) Offered
Replies
3
Views
451
BillSU
BillSU

Forum statistics

Threads
170,352
Messages
4,886,418
Members
5,995
Latest member
meierscreek

Share this page

Online statistics

Members online
323
Guests online
1,753
Total visitors
2,076
Totals may include hidden visitors.


...
Top Bottom