I think O'Neil and Kirst are the favorite but this is mostly a post-season award.
Raw numbers aren't everything, but its interesting that Dickson is averaging more points than Shellenberger 5.29 to 4.77, 4th to 12th), and yet Dickson didn't even make the top 25. Shellenberger has obviously been guarded by the top defender each game, and Dickson mostly the third, or even fourth, but still doesn't add up to me. Shellenberger could very easily go on a massive run in the tournament, but not sure he's one of the top five players in the country right now.
Feels like Kirst and Adler probably split the vote being teammates but kind of feels like Adler should have made the top five. Of course Cornell didn't play an ACC team this year so that perhaps hurt his candidacy as well.
Dordevic is having a great season but still only 14th in Points Per Game. I would think someone like Adler, or Dickson, could be nominated over someone like him as well.