So this is an interesting discussion because we clearly view Brown through two very different lenses. I don't really disagree with much of what you point out. The only quibble I have is that he absolutely was a facilitator when our offense was clicking in Feb/early March. He averaged 3.0 assists/game from Feb. on (11 games) and we ran a lot of high-ball screen, short roll action in that stretch. He wasn't a point forward, per se, but that's not an occasional assist. We rarely have 2-guards who average that many assists (JJ would kill for those numbers, for example).
The only other point I'd make is that you don't average 10 ppg on dunks/layups unless you are getting to good spots. It's not simply standing there and putting the ball in the basket now and then.
That said, I get what you're saying about generating his own offense. The question of whether he is capable of that or not is moot, since he's no longer here, but you are right -- very few jumpers, no low-post scoring, no face-up scoring.
But, Brown did so many other things on the floor. His usage rate was miniscule and his fg attempts were paltry, yet he still produced points and assists. He was a really tough defender all year, he was tough on the glass and even if you don't love the advanced metrics, he graded out high on all of them. I also believe he has the ability and work ethic to improve. He had not hit his ceiling as a player.
So, I doubt we're going to land in the same place on how we view Brown, but replacing him is going to be difficult. And, important to note here, all those things you say Brown couldn't do, are things players do when the stop the ball. Iso scoring, post-up offense, bigs with face-up games -- those aren't cuts, screens, rim runs, transition, rolls, passing, etc. So you're saying our offense will be great without ball stoppers, but the guy who never stopped the ball but managed to produce anyway is the guy you don't care about losing? Just not sure i see the logic there.
losing brown hurts...didnt want to lose him.
the thought of him going to duke to be a bench utility big instead of the exact same role at syracuse is nauseating.
having a BACKUP big who can do what he did to fill out the roster would be great, imo
i just see him for what he is - a tweener...not a center...not an offensive threat on offense...a defensive power forward...who can finish when open but cant do much when guarded. who also got abused by quite a few bigs in ACC despite also being great at deflections, steals, etc...clemson va tech, lousiville duke unc all had their way down low on brown's watch ...but people are just conveniently forgetting that for whatver reason...baffles me
he did get a bit better at passing the ball...there were games in feb march where he had some good passing BUT he simply isnt a player that can facilitate offense from the post.
clemson ABUSED him SO badly in a MUST WIN game...last game of the season. i mean, I dont want to hate on him...but I just think we need to look at him for what he is...and not overglorify what he did and was capable of.
I start both freeman and lmapkin over him. now if freeman shows to not be ready ...then I would reconsider, and start brown...
BUT...
and this is MY MAIN point
im so tired of the profiles of players that JB sought out...
bigs who can barely do anything on offense...can barely dribble pass etc..incapable on offense...who were guided to just hustle play d and stay near the hoop...paired with ball dominant iso guards...I hate that style of roster and the basketball it breeds
i hate watching offense by syracuse when they have 3 players that can do anything with the ball on offense...and watching how good teams clamp down those 3 players accordingly and the entrie offense grinds to a halt
now brown...was a bit better than incompetent on offense...but only slightly so
i hear your point about iso moves and having them creates waht I complained about but IMPORTANTLY it is about what the defense can do scheme wise - same way having a shooter gives space...having a big that can finish when guarded opens up everything on offense for the guards etc...
judging on reds portal add...i think he sees the same
hes picked up 3 good passers - he will have a team next year that can pass the ball
all 3 portal adds can pass assist and score...all 3 averaged double digit scoring last year, too
I MUCh prefer this approach.
im tired of the chukwus and taylors of the world who literally cannot do anything with the ball and hide in the offense etc
soooo tired of watching the orange try to play 3 or 4 on 5 on offense
brown is not quite that - but like I said ...I think people are inflating his skillset and abilities now that he left.
i expect him to be a defensive sub forward next year for duke...and I think its actually kinda silly of him to want that for himself but to each his own
and with that said...I want the coaches to add a defensive big that can do a lot of what brown did...and newsflash...it wont be hard to find someone like that (maybe not quite as good...but no matter)
the percentage of bigs who can play defense is much higher than the percentage who can play offense...so replacing a defensive big isnt really that serious of an issue, imo