I think there are two different factors being intertwined here:
- Is Edwards a good prospect who can play at the ACC level, who has value as a long term strategic asset?
- Can / will Edwards contribute as a high level as a freshman?
I get that there is a need next year, but question 2 shouldn't invalidate question 1. Bigs often need a year or two to acclimate to the college game.
Ultimately, I think we're going to ride or die with Sidibe / Marek. Really need Sidibe to bounce back, and actually be able to work on his game this offseason, instead of just recovering from surgery.
Or land a grad transfer who can contribute immediately.