I can only believe that the SJU fans over there saying, with a straight face, that SJU is NYC's team are the old school BE guys that were around for Mullin, Berry, etc. St. john's hasn't been NYC's team for almost 20 years. They have been a victim of their own mediocrity over that time. They can't keep players there, they can't keep the players who are there on the court, etc.
As a kid who came of age during the REAL BE (first decade), Next to my Orange blood, I have always respected the Johnnies. I still root for them when they arent playing us. They were my adopted 2nd team back then...because they hated GTown as much as we did.
I think the facts speak for themselves on this one, though. Syracuse sells out MSG. SJU doesn't even have more fans than Syracuse when they play each other at MSG. That speaks louder than words.