ED vs. TD - serious question

[hungrychuck]

I can't exactly how I'll judge one against the other. As has been stated, numbers won't tell the story. McNabb was better than a bunch of qbs with better numbers that were his contemporaries, especially his senior year. How do I know? I watched him. That's how I'll judge our any of our players.

Come on, that's crazy.

What you saw didn't happen until you're able to view the stat sheet after the game.

That is the only way you'll ever know what you saw.

 

[OttoinGrotto]

Arguably, right now is the highest in esteem Dungey has been held.

 

[bigmike]

I expect to form my opinion on this in 2021 or 2022.

 

[hungrychuck]

Arguably, right now is the highest in esteem Dungey has been held.

If true, that's shameful.

 

[4the Dubbz]

Should have been with us in Korea. The lines in the morning at the clinic went out the door and down the block.

take your doxy lol

 

[donniesyracuse]

What makes this question so serious?

 

[phil77]

The legend of ED continues to grow...

 

[Forza Azzurri]

I agree about he arm talent but totally disagree about what he could do behind Clemson’s OL. He has shown horrendous instincts. That isn’t the OLs fault. People forget how bad that INT was last year vs UNC. They forget the WMU and ND games.

Hopefully, over the next two years, we'll get to see him play behind an Oline that is at least serviceable to see who is right...

 

[Cusefan0307]

Jury's out on how good TD will be, but arm strength is the most overrated attribute when judging a QB.