I'm sure Chesney could have P5 guys say he is ready too. Both guys have their flaws and I am sure every legit candidate we were considering had them too.It means that Chesney has never held a P5 job and I wasn't sold on him being ready for one now, especially at Syracuse. Nothing against the guy. Brown is ready for this, just ask Rhule and Smart.
I value scheme and organization just as much as talent. that said I totally get this hire and think it is worth the risk. As I stated earlier - good or bad we are back looking in 3 years.