On paper, I really like our recruiting, but the problem is that actual player production does not live up to recruiting, at least in the first year. I see numerous 4 and 5 star freshmen at other schools contributing, year after year, during the season and well into the NCAA but not at SU. Of the players you mention, as freshmen; Ennis was great, Dion was OK. MCW and Melo were busts but fab as sophomores, as was Rak's senior year. DCII struggled as a soph before his injury. When was the last time we had a freshman 4* play big, CJ Fair? Shouldn't we expect at least half of our 5*s to be good as freshmen? I don't know why our recruiting doesn't correlate better with performance. Maybe just a statistical flunk, but I'm not a fan of JB's quick hook with younger players because I think it affects their confidence, expecially with scoring.
The lack of outside shooting and scoring in general is another problem which might, or might not, be related to recruiting. I think the staff has recognized this and made an adjustment with the 2015 class, which I like and have high hopes for.