Game Times! | Page 2 | Syracusefan.com

Game Times!

You're conveniently failing to mention the fact he's lining up Dungey's chest in the 1st photo & then the plain of that target changes in the 2nd due to ED being wrapped from behind. Mind you these 2 photos are probably .5 seconds apart. I still don't think there was intent to injure or that he was "instructed" to knock ED out, as has been suggested by many here. He was looking to deliver a hard hit on the QB, nothing more. Though obviously not as egregious, I think that, based upon intent, Kendall Coleman's helmet-to-helmet hit on Wake's QB 4 seconds after he released the ball last year was "dirtier". I don't recall anyone wanting him suspended for the remainder of the season or even charged with assault like some wanted the CMU LB. I know I'm in the minority here & this weill likely get flamed but sorry, I just don't see this as dirty.

18792983-mmmain.jpg

We disagree. I think it is dirty. I think Mark's shot clearly shows the CMU kid looking right at Dungey from 7-8 yards away knowing full well the ball has left his hand. He can also see a player is wrapping him up and Dungey is on his way down. That results in Mitch needing to go low to ensure a nice head shot while Dungey's knees are on the ground. I don't recall Coleman's but if you have a video, post away.
 
We disagree. I think it is dirty. I think Mark's shot clearly shows the CMU kid looking right at Dungey from 7-8 yards away knowing full well the ball has left his hand. He can also see a player is wrapping him up and Dungey is on his way down. That results in Mitch needing to go low to ensure a nice head shot while Dungey's knees are on he ground. I don't recall Coleman's but if you have a video, post away.
Fair enough. I can see where you're coming from. I believe Coleman was ejected & suspended for the following game, if memory serves.
 
You're conveniently failing to mention the fact he's lining up Dungey's chest in the 1st photo & then the plain of that target changes in the 2nd due to ED being wrapped from behind. Mind you these 2 photos are probably .5 seconds apart, if that.. I still don't think there was intent to injure or that he was "instructed" to knock ED out, as has been suggested by many here. He was looking to deliver a hard hit on the QB, nothing more. Though obviously not as egregious, I think that, based upon intent, Kendall Coleman's helmet-to-helmet hit on Wake's QB 4 seconds after he released the ball last year was "dirtier". I don't recall anyone wanting him suspended for the remainder of the season or even charged with assault like some wanted the CMU LB. I know I'm in the minority here & this weill likely get flamed but sorry, I just don't see this as dirty & am certainly not going into that game hoping for "revenge" on a college student. I think the death threats he received from SU fans were retaliation enough but to each their own.
The ball was out...he is a D-1 player. His reactions and maneuverability should be in the Top 5% of humans. He delivered a cheap shot.

Coleman's penalty was debatable and Wolford didn't leave with a concussion.
 
Fair enough. I can see where you're coming from. I believe Coleman was ejected & suspended for the following game, if memory serves.
He was ejected and missed the first half of the next game due to penalty. He was flagged for targeting just like CMU's player...they were not equal.
 
The ball was out...he is a D-1 player. His reactions and maneuverability should be in the Top 5% of humans. He delivered a cheap shot.

Coleman's penalty was debatable and Wolford didn't leave with a concussion.
I hear you. I don't recall Coleman's being debateable at all, it was pretty obvious. Also, I don't think injury or lackthereof changes intent. I guess I'm just not comfortable with the talk of "revenge" or "retaliation" & the threats that this kid has & will continue to receive for making a mistake in the heat of the moment. Agree to disagree, I don't want to derail this thread that should be about the great tailgates you all put on.
 
The 330P start is good news for that punk a** from CMU who cheap shot Dungey, he can load up on painkillers all day before we tear him apart.

Is he still on the team?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
172,260
Messages
5,006,679
Members
6,024
Latest member
shoresy

Online statistics

Members online
255
Guests online
2,742
Total visitors
2,997


...
Top Bottom