Joe Filardi

[23Zone]

Filardi gets ND, Carney gets BC (hopefully).

Live fire tryout, get stuff on tape. See who they prep, exhibit leadership, handle the pressure.

Live game reps are better than running scout team.

Would prefer Villari and the wildcat with a ton of trick plays against the Irish. Have absolutely nothing to loose.

 

[Scooch]

It just doesn’t matter. If Filardi ever starts a football game at QB after this season then the program has truly collapsed.

 

[upperdeck]

I dont think people really watched how he played and just saw the passing. He was nervous for sure and inaccurate. But he did a bunch of things right that dont show in the stats given how bad our protection is,

 

[PhatOrange]

I dont think people really watched how he played and just saw the passing. He was nervous for sure and inaccurate. But he did a bunch of things right that dont show in the stats given how bad our protection is,

What are the excuses when the protection is good?, because the protection is not always bad.

 

[CbusCuse]

I dont think people really watched how he played and just saw the passing. He was nervous for sure and inaccurate. But he did a bunch of things right that dont show in the stats given how bad our protection is,

He's an undersized true freshman that was running scout team stuff just prior. He threw like he was very nervous and his head was spinning which is understandable. Hard to garner too much definitively on his future at QB from what we have seen thus far. Wish he could play in an easier game against an easier defense and us having a healthier o-line. It is what it is I guess.

 

[Archbold44]

I dont think people really watched how he played and just saw the passing. He was nervous for sure and inaccurate. But he did a bunch of things right that dont show in the stats given how bad our protection is,

Agree. Looked a lot more composed against Miami. I think it is a no-brainer to give him PT against ND. I think I would start Collins and have him on a short leash before Filardi gets some PT.

 

[GoSU96]

It just doesn’t matter. If Filardi ever starts a football game at QB after this season then the program has truly collapsed.

Bench depth.

 

[PeteCalvin]

Can’t we bring back JG3 for football? He was a pretty damn good QB too.

 

[richmondcuse03]

I dont think people really watched how he played and just saw the passing. He was nervous for sure and inaccurate. But he did a bunch of things right that dont show in the stats given how bad our protection is,

I thought same. The things he did wrong -- namely accuracy -- shouldn't be that bad again. I chalked it up to first game and a lack of timing with guys he's barely played with. He made the right reads and decisions at least...

 

[Chip]

Bench depth.

Agree if he sticks around.

Maybe he's never ready to play at this level, but I'd at least like to see him get more than a short week promotion from scout team to starter as a true freshman before making that determination.

 

[JeremyCuse]

He's an undersized true freshman that was running scout team stuff just prior. He threw like he was very nervous and his head was spinning which is understandable. Hard to garner too much definitively on his future at QB from what we have seen thus far. Wish he could play in an easier game against an easier defense and us having a healthier o-line. It is what it is I guess.

This ^, your talking about a True frosh lax scholarship player who thought his chances at starting at QB were as good as someone from this board getting his 1st start (as a true freshman) in primetime vs a Bill Belichick defense. What exactly did people think was gonna happen? This isn't Donovan Mcnabb in his rookie season were talking about here.

 

[Scooch]

Bench depth.

For lacrosse?

 

[OrangeXtreme]

 

[NineOneSeven]

Godspeed, soldier.

How many pass attempts before we get to 5 completions? I’m going with 19.

 

[djorange1989]

It just doesn’t matter. If Filardi ever starts a football game at QB after this season then the program has truly collapsed.

Meatballs reference! It’s just doesn’t matter! It just doesn’t matter! Bill Murray as QB on Saturday?

 

[RMH44]

Filardi gets ND, Carney gets BC (hopefully).

Live fire tryout, get stuff on tape. See how they prep, exhibit leadership, handle the pressure.

Live game reps are better than running scout team.

This is what I heard from a reliable source. Carney starts against BC...ND, probably Collins with a dash of Filadi??

Part of building culture is keeping your promises and managing expectations. Fran made a promise to Luke and his parents that he would red-shirt Luke this year. Promise kept! As a result, I'm reasonably sure you won't see Luke in the portal.

If all this is true, I think that helps explain why play calls were so limited for Luke. If he throws the ball all over the yard, fans would be clamoring why he didn't play more. Temper expectations by having him hand the ball off in his limited playing time. I'm looking forward to his start against BC.

 

[OttoinGrotto]

Carney gets BC (hopefully).

If he doesn't I say we riot.

 

[RMH44]

This ^, your talking about a True frosh lax scholarship player who thought his chances at starting at QB were as good as someone from this board getting his 1st start (as a true freshman) in primetime vs a Bill Belichick defense. What exactly did people think was gonna happen? This isn't Donovan Mcnabb in his rookie season were talking about here.

And Donovan was a RS Frosh...

 

[EnviroSciGuy]

STILL can't believe Collins is so bad he gets beat out by a true freshman walk-on. I wonder what Brian Kelly said to Fran prior to Collins' transfer. Fran got fleeced!

There's a post in the ERob/Nixon thread that probably comes pretty close.

 

[GoSU96]

If he doesn't I say we riot.

Sure, sounds like a plan

 

[cali315phan]

Jakhari must be REALLY bad

 

[Scooch]

Meatballs reference! It’s just doesn’t matter! It just doesn’t matter! Bill Murray as QB on Saturday?

Even if we play so far over our heads that our noses bleed for a week to ten days, it still doesn’t matter, because the girls are gonna go out with Notre Dame anyway, because they got all the money!

 

[23Zone]

STILL can't believe Collins is so bad he gets beat out by a true freshman walk-on. I wonder what Brian Kelly said to Fran prior to Collins' transfer. Fran got fleeced!

"Trust me ..."

 

[OrangeTarheel]

This is what I heard from a reliable source. Carney starts against BC...ND, probably Collins with a dash of Filadi??

Part of building culture is keeping your promises and managing expectations. Fran made a promise to Luke and his parents that he would red-shirt Luke this year. Promise kept! As a result, I'm reasonably sure you won't see Luke in the portal.

If all this is true, I think that helps explain why play calls were so limited for Luke. If he throws the ball all over the yard, fans would be clamoring why he didn't play more. Temper expectations by having him hand the ball off in his limited playing time. I'm looking forward to his start against BC.

I’ve thought the same thing. Hope Carney impresses when we see him again

 

[CbusCuse]

This is what I heard from a reliable source. Carney starts against BC...ND, probably Collins with a dash of Filadi??

Part of building culture is keeping your promises and managing expectations. Fran made a promise to Luke and his parents that he would red-shirt Luke this year. Promise kept! As a result, I'm reasonably sure you won't see Luke in the portal.

If all this is true, I think that helps explain why play calls were so limited for Luke. If he throws the ball all over the yard, fans would be clamoring why he didn't play more. Temper expectations by having him hand the ball off in his limited playing time. I'm looking forward to his start against BC.

I figured as much about the redshirt even though most posters seemed to say redshirts don't matter, burn it. But if the kid came in with the plan of redshirting and was sold on that well...

But I can't say i agree with not giving him much to do in a game just because he's redshirting. That doesn't make sense to me. You play to win and you and him both want to get him valuable experience. And If he's good and plays good then maybe he changes his mind and wants to play. So not sure i would buy that the reason he didn't have much of a workload is solely because of the redshirting thing.