I like all 4 guards. Everyone wants to rag on Carey, but I think he’s the best penetrator of the bunch—even though he still struggles with turnovers. fwiw, so did Scoop. When you’re trying to get in the lane and make something happen, you’re taking a risk. I think Goodine has potential going to the basket as well. TBD on Girard. I think he’s steady but has a ways to go to be a good driver. And that’s an essential skill to have as a PG. Look at Frank last season. He wouldn’t drive the ball into the lane and he became a one dimensional player.Goodine played so much better when he was taken off the ball in the second half. I've seen nothing in two fake games against overmatched teams to suggest he's a point guard in any way. His quick run of buckets in the second half was impressive, though his only way to real playing time is probably at the 1. There are creative ways to solve that (more Elijah handling the ball), but it's kind of a problem.
My guess is that if Carey keeps his defense solid and his reckless turnovers/dumb jumpers to a minimum, he'll hold on to his position.