Luke Carney

[powdersmack]

That is a very tough call in today's day and age, to bring in a true freshman, who might literally be very talented. However people very close to him could very well say I do not think that is a good idea, we had every intention on red shirting this year. We live in a different age. Look at Eric Dungey, my gosh how he did not get a red shirt year is criminal. Tough call all the way around no matter what. I truly love how Ricky competed to the end. Really great kid, However defensive backs truly truly love quarterbacks like him. He locks in and does not leave, with no check down at this point. I trust that changes, I believe he improved in the second half for sure. Certainly not the greatest still however improvement noted. The 2nd interception, I will be curious to see who that is on. In any event very bad communication and this team better not quit on him.

What?!? Seriously, what?!

 

[GHLF]

I thought it was pretty self explanatory? These things do happen, especially with Angeli coming back for potentially two more years... Did you play football or see where we Live Today?

 

[GHLF]

If I was his agent would already be talking to teams closer to home. If he can't get into a game like that with Steve and Rickie coming back better to go somewhere else. That way you don't burn a redshirt year for nothing. Staying here you wouldn't see the field until your junior year.

Definitely valid points, so many variables

 

[SuFTW]

By continuing to play Rickie, Fran has signaled that he doesn’t believe that Luke can help us. He, and the rest of the QBs, must be pretty bad..

Fran is signaling that he is stubborn.

 

[Sammy407]

I say take the risk on Carney, he's got 3 games left to burn before his redshirt expires, even throw Williams or Blein into the conversation. Something has to be done to save this season.

 

[Mchandl8]

If Luke is worse than Rickie… we have SERIOUS problems

 

[DonutHole]

When will he get his chance to play? Rickie just isn’t the guy and I want to see what the future of this program Luke has in his game.

Maybe sub in Dan Villari again.

 

[Greeracuse]

Two weeks to get Luke ready for Pitt. It seems clear that Rickie will never be the answer at this level, so why not build for the future. What do we have to lose?

 

[bothsocksup]

If I was his agent would already be talking to teams closer to home. If he can't get into a game like that with Steve and Rickie coming back better to go somewhere else. That way you don't burn a redshirt year for nothing. Staying here you wouldn't see the field until your junior year.

What a loser comment. Your the parent that ruins youth sports

 

[OrangeXtreme]

 

[Cuse4455]

Id rather listen to a turd, then listen to nasally Paulie.

 

[orangencpolice]

We're gonna take an L for the bye week. I can feel it.

And I will watch the entire game wondering what went wrong.

 

[OttosShoes]

I’m not assessing his knowledge of the team.

I’m assessing his ability to stubbornly defy conventional wisdom and/or his ability to have appropriate depth at QB. If this is *actually* QB2 then we needed two in the portal.

 

[Tango32]

I like Fran but pretending he's beyond reproach is so stupid. Tucker, Dungey, etc were buried on the depth chart until desperately pressed into service. Different HC I know, but come on... it happens a lot everywhere

 

[Archbold44]

Rickie led the team in rushing. Luke seems to be dual threat. And that is not even considering Williams and Belin and Villari. Losing WRs left and right. Let’s start morphing the 2025 offense into one using QB mobility. Next year we can go back to Nixon’s bread and butter. We put WRs into the NFL with a triple option. Nobody’s stats or career should take a serious hit.