Official 2018 New York Football GIANTS Drive for 5 Thread

[MikeSU02]

the bad part is the extension and the cap hit the Giants take this year for sure.

the picks and Peppers are great capital. there is nothing wrong with drafting Saquan or standing with Eli...but at some point here, we need to address the QB of the future for sure.

Would you:
1) Trade a pick (or picks) for Rosen if Zona takes Kyler?
2) Pick Haskins?
3) Assume we'll have a tough year and grab a guy from 2020?

 

[Bayside44]

that was Bloomberg

The current dummy is too.

 

[KaiserUEO]

The current dummy is too.

Well that at least makes sense.

Good lord...

 

[bpo57]

that was Bloomberg

No DeBlas is a sox fan, too. Tho he probably couldn't identify three players. Kinda like John Kerry when asked his favorite sox player he said Manny Ortiz.

 

[MikeSU02]

 

[Alsacs]

The Giants roster construction is simply amazing bad.
I mean Tate is good but why pay him that much for a rebuild.

 

[Melancer46]

The Giants roster construction is simply amazing bad.
I mean Tate is good but why pay him that much for a rebuild.

I’m not sure they know yet whether or not they’re rebuilding.

Do they trade Shepard now or are they gonna try to move one of them to the outside?

 

[Alsacs]

I’m not sure they know yet whether or not they’re rebuilding.

Do they trade Shepard now or are they gonna try to move one of them to the outside?

If the Giants draft DK Metcalf at 6 that will be awesome to read this thread.

The trade of OBJ just doesn’t make sense if they wanted Tate.
Put OBJ with Tate and Barkley that offense is top 5 skill position wise.

 

[OrangeDW]

If the Giants draft DK Metcalf at 6 that will be awesome to read this thread.

The trade of OBJ just doesn’t make sense if they wanted Tate.
Put OBJ with Tate and Barkley that offense is top 5 skill position wise.

They’re making so many moves and have so many draft picks that it’s hard to rate any of these moves in a vacuum.

I think this is a situation where their off-season can’t be properly evaluated until it’s over.

 

[KaiserUEO]

If the Giants draft DK Metcalf at 6 that will be awesome to read this thread.

The trade of OBJ just doesn’t make sense if they wanted Tate.
Put OBJ with Tate and Barkley that offense is top 5 skill position wise.

OBJ was an arsehole.

They screwed up giving him $$.

Eli is still a top 20, I say 15, QB when he has time they are rebuilding with an eye on both the present and future.

Some QB is going to get a Ferrari...

 

[MikeSU02]

They’re making so many moves and have so many draft picks that it’s hard to rate any of these moves in a vacuum.

I think this is a situation where their off-season can’t be properly evaluated until it’s over.

I’m very wary of Gettelman, but agree with you, let’s see where we land.

I need to see what the QB plan is (Rosen, Haskins, Tank for Tua) before I can fully know.

 

[Shawn91111]

the bad part is the extension and the cap hit the Giants take this year for sure.

the picks and Peppers are great capital. there is nothing wrong with drafting Saquan or standing with Eli...but at some point here, we need to address the QB of the future for sure.

When would this "addressing the QB of the future"actually take place when the time was last year, this coming year as well.

 

[KaiserUEO]

When would this "addressing the QB of the future"actually take place when the time was last year, this coming year as well.

1 of the 3 ‘franchise’ QBs from last year will be traded for a 4 soon.

Giants QB just completed 66% of his passes for 4300 yards.

They need one, but he was not why they lost last year.

 

[Shawn91111]

1 of the 3 ‘franchise’ QBs from last year will be traded for a 4 soon.

Giants QB just completed 66% of his passes for 4300 yards.

They need one, but he was not why they lost last year.

Right, nothing like dink and dunk to Barkley to get that % up, stop looking at basic stats.

 

[KaiserUEO]

When would this "addressing the QB of the future"actually take place when the time was last year, this coming year as well.

1 of the 3 ‘franchise’ QBs from last year will be teaded for a 4 soon.

Right, nothing like dink and dunk to Barkley to get that % up, stop looking at basic stats.

Go look up how many yards went to all Giants RBs.

Then look up Brady & Rivers.

Then come back and apologize.

 

[Shawn91111]

1 of the 3 ‘franchise’ QBs from last year will be teaded for a 4 soon.

Go look up how many yards went to all Giants RBs.

Then look up Brady & Rivers.

Then come back and apologize.

Apologize? I'm not the one putting Eli on a pedestal

 

[KaiserUEO]

Apologize? I'm not the one putting Eli on a pedestal

Neither am I.

But I deal in he world of fact and not conjecture and flat out lies. I do my own research and do not regurgitate uniformed media hacks sad takes to get hits on their twitter or article by slamming a NYC icon.

 

[chugg21]

1 of the 3 ‘franchise’ QBs from last year will be traded for a 4 soon.

That's so dumb that it invalidates almost anything that you post.

 

[Shawn91111]

Neither am I.

But I deal in he world of fact and not conjecture and flat out lies. I do my own research and do not regurgitate uniformed media hacks sad takes to get hits on their twitter or article by slamming a NYC icon.

lol keep putting him on that pedestal, it has been your MO for a long time, and has just become sad over the last few years

 

[KaiserUEO]

That's so dumb that it invalidates almost anything that you post.

Nope.

He better be traded for a 1...maybe a 2.

Anything else and I am more than validated...again.

 

[chugg21]

Nope.

He better be traded for a 1...maybe a 2.

Anything else and I am more than validated...again.

How do you say a 4 repeatedly but then maybe a 2 validates that? Those are worlds apart.

 

[KaiserUEO]

How do you say a 4 repeatedly but then maybe a 2 validates that? Those are worlds apart.

Who cares?

He was a can’t miss 1.

He’s already being shopped, likely for less than a 1.

A 2 is laughable, what is he a Honda Civic??

A 3 is the rumor, I’m on the Internet here saying a 4 for effect, why do I have to explain this??

 

[Bayside44]

Who cares?

He was a can’t miss 1.

He’s already being shopped, likely for less than a 1.

A 2 is laughable, what is he a Honda Civic??

A 3 is the rumor, I’m on the Internet here saying a 4 for effect, why do I have to explain this??

Friday happy hour start early today?

 

[KaiserUEO]

Friday happy hour start early today?

 

[Finwad32]

Starting to see Metcalf show up for the Jints... at 6!

I just want this written somewhere... if that’s the pick, it will be a horrendous experiment.

Dude looks like a body builder and runs real fast in a straight line, so he’s probably the best WR in the draft. Perfect example of combine inflation. Who was saying his name before Indianapolis?

I wouldn’t spend a 1 on him if he played for free.