Can people who only make it to a game once or twice a year get into the North Manley lot? To me, the big downside to the Fine Lot is that it is hard for people to get to who don't have a pass, especially if they are bringing stuff. The ideal location would support having people buy a pass for all games or pay on a game by game basis as needed.
I am not a fan of shuttle buses either (I will walk no matter what) but as others have said, while the walk from North Manley might be double the length, it is flat, which might make it a wash for some. Heck, just having the option of not walking period might make it more attractive for some.
Would be nice to have a lot we should be able to count on for many years. North Manley sounds like it could fit that bill.
Still like the big lot on Harrison owned by the Syracuse school district. Tons of room, very cheap and anyone that wants to can park there. Easy to get in and out of as well. But you end up maybe 10 blocks from the Dome and it is all uphill to get there. And there is no bus shuttle. I suspect this would be a big problem for many of the Fine Lot folks.