Team AJ or Team Edouard?

[Marroniac]

First things first, my sincere apologies for the Twilight reference.

I'm curious how many of us think AJ is the QB of our future and how many are all in on Alin.
Wilson and Kimble supporters speak up as well.

I've always been in the Long camp. I like his accuracy and work ethic. Alin fans point to his athletic ability and arm strength.

 

[Libero2]

Could we watch the kids play first before having to decide if they are the best thing for our future?

 

[Cootface]

Could we watch the kids play first before having to decide if they are the best thing for our future?

Where's the fun in that?

 

[Marroniac]

Could we watch the kids play first before having to decide if they are the best thing for our future?

You can have an opinion before they play. Maybe this would have been better suited for the recruiting board.

 

[cuseinchina]

You can have an opinion before they play. Maybe this would have been better suited for the recruiting board.

75% of these people are on campus, and one has supposedly come and left temporarily to return in January. This is the right spot for this.

It's fun to speculate. We definitely need a QB. I worry AJ will do well enough to keep Edouard away but not good enough to take us next level. It's really too bad he's not on campus now...this is the moment.

 

[IthacaBarrel]

I just think long is too small and if you are that small you have to do everything else really well, we shall se. Eduard. I would like to see Kimble play

 

[Marroniac]

75% of these people are on campus, and one has supposedly come and left temporarily to return in January. This is the right spot for this.

It's fun to speculate. We definitely need a QB. I worry AJ will do well enough to keep Edouard away but not good enough to take us next level. It's really too bad he's not on campus now...this is the moment.

That's an interesting concern. On the flip side, since the day he committed, I was always worried that Alin would be the one preventing AJ from getting an opportunity.

 

[Libero2]

You can have an opinion before they play. Maybe this would have been better suited for the recruiting board.

I'm tuned in to the recruiting board as well.

In my eyes this is Long vs. Edouard as I expect both are better than Kimble and Wilson. Since Edouard is not here, by default that would make A.J. my choice. That said its a little ridiculous to label a kid who couldn't win the backup job outright this spring as the future before he takes a snap. Ditto for Edouard who was on campus for all of 5 minutes

 

[sufandu]

You can have an opinion before they play.

I'm not sure how. We know nothing about the attributes you mentioned in your OP and won't until we see them play.

 

[Rocco]

McNabb

 

[orange79]

I'm not sure how. We know nothing about the attributes you mentioned in your OP and won't until we see them play.

It's ridiculously easy to have an opinion without having seen them play.

Oh - you meant an informed opinion...

 

[OrangeXtreme]

Jack Brotzki.

 

[anomander]

Nunes

 

[retro44]

Jack Brotzki.

Ha!!!!

 

[Bornorange]

Could we watch the kids play first before having to decide if they are the best thing for our future?

No way. I love to make decisions based on hunches and E.S.P.

 

[Marroniac]

You guys realize that fantasy football, a competition centered around projecting performance on the football field, is a billion dollar industry, right?

I'm sorry for posting this thread if it offended some of you. I thought it would be fun to discuss this before we see them play and the timing seemed right for that.

 

[Crusty]

First, I am rooting for all of them - they look Orange to me.

As most know, Autin Wilson has always been my favorite. He may have the best/most accurate arm with a great long ball since...since...well, in a long time.

Just gotta love AJ. The kids has a Syracuse tatoo for Pete's sake. If he is everything people are saying he is, then he could be a very special transformative player. Part of me thinks he is.

I just don't know enough about Kimble to make an assessment. Hopefully, he is still learning and will surprise everyone next Spring.

It's close, but I am still going with Austin Wilson because I want to see that arm in the Dome for the next 3 1/2 years.

 

[OttoinGrotto]

I mostly just want to make sure one turns out really good, but I am partial to AJ Long.

 

[Bornorange]

As most know, Autin Wilson has always been my favorite. He may have the best/most accurate arm with a great long ball since...since...well, in a long time.

Todd Philcox or Donnie.

 

[jekelish]

Chad Elliott.

 

[orange79]

ChristoNorley

 

[jekelish]

No, seriously guys:

#DIXONTIME