Thamel: 12 Mid-Major Coaches on the Rise | Syracusefan.com

Thamel: 12 Mid-Major Coaches on the Rise

Whitey23

Twitter Wizard
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
13,008
Like
16,044
The small school uprising coincides with an expected historic rate of turnover among coaches in Power 5 conferences. Already there are already four Power 5 jobs open: Illinois, USC, Maryland and South Carolina. A flurry of others could become available, including Miami, Virginia Tech, Virginia, Syracuse, Iowa State, Indiana, Purdue, Colorado and Rutgers. Of those jobs, only Miami and Virginia Tech are considered among the upper-tier in their leagues.


12 Mid-Major Coaches on the Rise
Here are the top 12 mid-major head coaches who could be facing tough choices the next few months:

1. Justin Fuente, Memphis: His 19–3 record at Memphis the last two years is remarkable considering the program's history of ineptitude. There's a lot to like about Fuente, including his pedigree as an offensive assistant at TCU before coming to Memphis. Now that he has a signature victory, his phone will be ringing off the hook.

2. Matt Wells, Utah State: A 52–26 upset of No. 21 Boise wasn't as surprising as the tenor of it. The Aggies forced eight turnovers and the game could mark a paradigm change in the Mountain West, especially considering Boise beat Utah State 50–19 last season. Wells is 23–11 in his third season, and he'll be a top candidate for any Pac-12 jobs—non-USC division—that open.

3. Tom Herman, Houston: He's 6–0 through his six games as a head coach. Lack of head-coaching experience makes it tricky to put him ahead of more seasoned candidates, but he could have the largest upside. Herman has Houston ranked No. 21 despite being down three starters on the offensive line. His resume includes working under Urban Meyer, who has a solid track record of producing head coaches—Charlie Strong (Texas), Dan Mullen (Mississippi State), Doc Holliday (Marshall), Steve Addazio (Boston College), Kyle Whittingham (Utah) and Gary Andersen (Oregon State).

4. Bryan Harsin, Boise State: Harsin may have been No. 1 on this list before last weekend, as Boise won the Fiesta Bowl last season. But coaching is a week-to-week business and Harsin had a bad week against Utah State. Harsin's resume includes a 17–4 record at Boise, a 7-5 season at Arkansas State and coordinator experience at Texas. He likely doesn't have the juice for USC, but will be in the mix for a lot of jobs this fall.

5. Matt Campbell, Toledo: That Campbell is this far down the list is proof how stocked this class of mid-major coaches is. The No. 19 Rockets have upset Arkansas and Iowa State this season, and Campbell is 32–13 in his fourth full season as head coach. Campbell will be high on the list of a lot of Big Ten schools, as there's a flurry of jobs expected to open in the bottom-half of that league. A MAC title would be Toledo's first since 2004 and the final polish on Campbell's resume.

6. Matt Rhule, Temple: From getting kicked out of the Big East a decade ago to the Top 25, it's been quite a swing for Temple. Rhule picked up a signature victory over Penn State earlier this season, blowing out the Nittany Lions 27–10. Rhule has built the Owls with a slow burn through careful recruiting and player development, as Temple went 2–10 and 6–6 his first two seasons. He has a few more chances at hallmark wins this fall, as Temple hosts Notre Dame on Halloween and Memphis on Nov. 21.

7. Doc Holliday, Marshall: He's 29–6 the past three seasons, 3–0 in bowl games in his career and his teams play a wide-open style that's attractive to recruits and ADs. He's also a prolific recruiter of South Florida, which should put him in the mix at USF, UCF and Miami. Marshall is 6–1 and headed for another double-digit win season.

8. Rod Carey, Northern Illinois: Carey may have improved his resume most this season by NIU's strong showing at No. 1 Ohio State in a 20–13 loss in September. His 27–9 record and last year's MAC championship make him an obvious candidate for any Big Ten jobs that open. Carey is an Indiana graduate and could end up on that school's short list if the job opens.

9. Jeff Brohm, Western Kentucky: He's 14–6 through two seasons, including a victory over Vanderbilt earlier this year. Athletic directors want offense, and WKU is in the Top 10 in scoring offense, passing offense and total offense. Brohn is 44, played seven seasons in the NFL and has a showcase game at LSU on Saturday night.

10. Willie Fritz, Georgia Southern: Fritz has a strong track of winning everywhere he's gone, including a Sun Belt title his first season. Georgia Southern (5–1) went 8–0 in the league last year and is 14–4 in his two seasons there. Georgia Southern blew out Western Michigan earlier this season, and its only loss is to West Virginia. Fritz is 55, which means he's got one more stop in him.

11. Dino Babers, Bowling Green: The Falcons's 48–27 blowout victory at Maryland opened a lot of eyes, as did their win over Indiana last season. Babers brings a strong offensive pedigree; he learned under Art Briles at Baylor and helped develop Jimmy Garoppolo at Eastern Illinois. Babers inherited star quarterback Matt Johnson at Bowling Green and has turned him into No. 1 quarterback in the country in passing yards (2,891) and No. 3 in touchdown passes (24).

12. P.J. Fleck, Western Michigan: At 34, he's the youngest coach in the FBS and perhaps the most intriguing, with his endless stream of energy and catch phrases. His 12-19 record is offset, in part, by the best recruiting classes in the MAC the past two seasons. Western went 8–5 last year and has the talent to compete for the league title this season. It will be fun to see the Broncos play Toledo and Bowling Green in November.
 
I think HCSS deserves year 4, but if Coyle disagrees, there are some great candidates on there. Rhule is number 1 as far as I am concerned. Seems like the best fit for our program of any of the 12.
 
djorange1989 said:
I think HCSS deserves year 4, but if Coyle disagrees, there are some great candidates on there. Rhule is number 1 as far as I am concerned. Seems like the best fit for our program of any of the 12.

They'll be good coaches available whenever it happens. If it happens.
 
I think it's hilarious that people (not saying you, Whitey, this and other lists just makes me think of this) were grumbling about not hiring any more MAC level coaches...and now every list every poster puts out is riddled with guys like Matt Campbell, Dino Babers, Matt Rhule, etc.
 
Last edited:
Have to imagine with Coyle's affiliation (albeit past) with Boise St., Harsin likely to be a strong consideration?
 
Have to imagine with Coyle's affiliation (albeit past) with Boise St., Harsin likely to be a strong consideration?
I don't think he's a good fit for anyone outside the Pac-12 or Big XII. He's from Boise and has coached at Eastern Oregon, Texas, Arkansas State, and Boise State. The overwhelming majority of his recruits have come from California and distant second Texas.

I think the two that fit best at Syracuse are Matt Rhule and Doc Holliday.
 
Last edited:
Cool post, Whitey.

I'd love to see Shafer succeed here. Nothing would please me more. But if he doesn't take the next step, then I think some of the names on this list could be the direction we go.
 
Of this list I like Campbell. He's an interesting prospect.

He's young at 36 but has only been at Toledo. I like the diversity of his roster which is a nice mix of kids from OH<MD<PA<FL<MI among others. Places we should recruit so they obviously already have relationships in those places. Interesting to note his QB is former Plant QB Phil Ely
 
Last edited:
I think HCSS deserves year 4, but if Coyle disagrees, there are some great candidates on there. Rhule is number 1 as far as I am concerned. Seems like the best fit for our program of any of the 12.
I think Shafer deserves to complete his contract. One disturbing fact about him as a coach, he gets way to conservative and thinks his defense can carry the game. when Cuse gets up on an opponent, they take the foot off the Gas pedal. Nothing wrong with beating a team by 30 points. Shafer needs to be forced to retool his coaching staff! We need an experienced O line coach and D. backs coach.
 
I think it's hilarious that people (not saying you, Whitey, this and other lists just makes me think of this) were grumbling about not hiring any more MAC level coaches...and now every list every poster puts out is riddled with guys like Matt Campbell, Dino Babers, Matt Rhule, etc.

I don't understand the gripe about "no more MAC level coaches," but I'm all about the notion that we shouldn't serve as someone's first HC gig.
 
I think Shafer deserves to complete his contract. One disturbing fact about him as a coach, he gets way to conservative and thinks his defense can carry the game. when Cuse gets up on an opponent, they take the foot off the Gas pedal. Nothing wrong with beating a team by 30 points. Shafer needs to be forced to retool his coaching staff! We need an experienced O line coach and D. backs coach.
Does the fact that Steve Gregory was an NFL defense back make him a natural choice for DB coach, or does he need to coach a little more in the background before making the step?
 
I don't think he's a good fit for anyone outside the Pac-12 or Big XII. He's from Boise and has coached at Eastern Oregon, Texas, Arkansas State, and Boise State. The overwhelming majority of his recruits have come from California and distant second Texas.

I think the two that fit best at Syracuse are Matt Rhule and Doc Holliday.

Put me under the category of not being overly concerned with recruiting ties. Wins and good recruiting assistants (ala Acosta) brings good players. A little excitement doesn't hurt, either.
 
Does the fact that Steve Gregory was an NFL defense back make him a natural choice for DB coach, or does he need to coach a little more in the background before making the step?

He may not be up on the latest "team-building exercises" or have connections with all the high school coaches but I'd think he is qualified enough to teach our young men how to play the DB position. Bonus is maybe we could even sneak him into the game in a pinch.
 
Put me under the category of not being overly concerned with recruiting ties. Wins and good recruiting assistants (ala Acosta) brings good players. A little excitement doesn't hurt, either.

Id be somewhat concerned if a new hire were someone who isn't a cultural fit, or who hasn't recruited east of the rocky mountains before.
 
Next head coach to me should be a coach with HC experience, should have an offensive background with a proven college system that has demonstrated success running that system, have ties to our traditional recruiting areas or ties where we can recruit being in the ACC and also have demonstrated the ability to do more with less. A coach that can coach em up so to speak. I like Dino Babers a lot.

If smart, coach could also retain Daoust as the DC if they want to maintain some continuity if need be but could also be a HC/OC if they perform that role currently and spend money on an established DC. Just my 2 cents

Shafer gets to 5-7 that earns 4th year IMO, anything less why prolong the inevitable.
 
I want to see Shafer continue and succeed. An article on ACC Football Rx wants Matt Campbell to be the next coach.

http://accfootballrx.blogspot.com/2015/10/guest-article-coaching-carousel.html


"Syracuse Old -Scott Shaffer
New -Matt Campbell

Syracuse needs a program builder with a vision if they can't get a big splash head coach. They need to VASTLY improve their recruiting. Fans talk about how Shaffer has already improved recruiting, and he has, all the way up to... still last in the Atlantic division last year. Shaffer is a solid old school hard nose coach. A very likable guy. But Syracuse has to have a young fireball to close the deal with families in New Jersey, not just on the practice field. Why? Campbell has some wins under his belt he can point to and build upon. "We can do this BUT bigger". Whoever takes the job has an uphill climb. Clemson, FSU, UofL, and NCState have better talent in the division, BC, and Pitt have better coaches. Its a long way up for Cuse. A coach who can make something out of nothing is a good first step."
 
I guess that makes it official-Campbell it is;)

I want to see Shafer continue and succeed. An article on ACC Football Rx wants Matt Campbell to be the next coach.

http://accfootballrx.blogspot.com/2015/10/guest-article-coaching-carousel.html


"Syracuse Old -Scott Shaffer
New -Matt Campbell

Syracuse needs a program builder with a vision if they can't get a big splash head coach. They need to VASTLY improve their recruiting. Fans talk about how Shaffer has already improved recruiting, and he has, all the way up to... still last in the Atlantic division last year. Shaffer is a solid old school hard nose coach. A very likable guy. But Syracuse has to have a young fireball to close the deal with families in New Jersey, not just on the practice field. Why? Campbell has some wins under his belt he can point to and build upon. "We can do this BUT bigger". Whoever takes the job has an uphill climb. Clemson, FSU, UofL, and NCState have better talent in the division, BC, and Pitt have better coaches. Its a long way up for Cuse. A coach who can make something out of nothing is a good first step."
 
Id be somewhat concerned if a new hire were someone who isn't a cultural fit, or who hasn't recruited east of the rocky mountains before.

I hear you. I'm just saying if you interview a guy and based on his body of work you think he's THAT good, hire him. A guy like Urban Meyer would succeed anywhere. I think the same about Tom Herman.
 
I hear you. I'm just saying if you interview a guy and based on his body of work you think he's THAT good, hire him. A guy like Urban Meyer would succeed anywhere. I think the same about Tom Herman.

Campbell I believe worked for Meyer as a GA at Bowling Green.

He's an Offensive guy that's for sure. Won two D3 championships at Mount Union as OC/OL coach. 29-1 record

Record as an Assistant Coach

2003
Bowling Green, Graduate Assistant, 11-3
Motor City Bowl Champs

2004
Bowling Green, Graduate Assistant, 9-3
GMAC Bowl

2005
Mount Union, Offensive Coordinator/Offensive Line, 14-1
D-III National Champions

2006
Mount Union, Offensive Coordinator/Offensive Line, 15-0
D-III National Champions

2007
Bowling Green, Offensive Line, 8-5
GMAC Bowl

2008
Bowling Green, Offensive Line/Run-Game Coordinator, 6-6

2009
Toledo, Run-Game Coordinator/Offensive Line, 5-7

2010
Toledo, Offensive Coordinator/Offensive Line, 8-5
Little Caesars Pizza Bowl

2011
Toledo, Offensive Coordinator/Offensive Line, 8-4, Military Bowl Champions

Record as a Head Coach
2011: Toledo, 1-0 (0-0 MAC) Military Bowl Champions
2012: Toledo, 9-4 (6-2 MAC) Famous Idaho Potato Bowl
2013: Toledo, 7-5 (5-3 MAC)
2014: Toledo, 8-4 (6-1 MAC)
2015: Toledo, 4-0 (2-0 MAC)

His assistants are all real young to.
 
I want to see Shafer continue and succeed. An article on ACC Football Rx wants Matt Campbell to be the next coach.

http://accfootballrx.blogspot.com/2015/10/guest-article-coaching-carousel.html


"Syracuse Old -Scott Shaffer
New -Matt Campbell

Syracuse needs a program builder with a vision if they can't get a big splash head coach. They need to VASTLY improve their recruiting. Fans talk about how Shaffer has already improved recruiting, and he has, all the way up to... still last in the Atlantic division last year. Shaffer is a solid old school hard nose coach. A very likable guy. But Syracuse has to have a young fireball to close the deal with families in New Jersey, not just on the practice field. Why? Campbell has some wins under his belt he can point to and build upon. "We can do this BUT bigger". Whoever takes the job has an uphill climb. Clemson, FSU, UofL, and NCState have better talent in the division, BC, and Pitt have better coaches. Its a long way up for Cuse. A coach who can make something out of nothing is a good first step."

That site is loaded with typos. Can't take the guy seriously. Shaffer. Goldon.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,447
Messages
4,891,587
Members
5,998
Latest member
powdersmack

Online statistics

Members online
78
Guests online
1,084
Total visitors
1,162


...
Top Bottom