THE AFTERMATH
The Herald-American had two pictures on the front of the sports page. One is captioned “Look Ma, No Hands!” after the old commercial. A second period Holy Cross pass went over Ed Hayes’ head. Of greater import, (and size) is the shot of Chuck Strid, Jerry Cashman and Ed Bailey racing to see which would be the first to pounce on Billy Smithers’ fumble in the end zone for the clinching score. This one was called “Linemen’s Delight”. SU players are all in orange from helmet to pants, (it comes out as nearly black in the pictures. Four pages later there was “Unique Numbers Game”, two shots showing SU’s #16, Jim Ridlon, chasing Holy Cross’s #16, Jack Ringel, across the goal line and then Holy Cross’s #85, Dick Bernadino chasing Nick Baccile, #85, across the same goal line on separate plays.
The full page 65 was devoted to pictures of the game. The top picture, “One for Jim”, showing #44 sweeping to the right to score SU’s fourth TD. The picture is not too clear but someone is blocking the nearest Crusader and Jim has plenty of room to waltz into the end zone past that block. Three other defenders are running toward the play but they are just spectators. Below that Jim Brown, (with that mysterious large white stripe on his helmet: other players have narrow blue stripes- SU had game captains that year so that’s not it), leaps with and Al Cann leap simultaneously to try to intercept a pass to Dick Bernadino. Neither got this one but the pass was deflected. The shot of Bernadino shows off Holy Cross’s uniform: purple helmets with double white stripes and the number on the side, rings around the shoulders on the white jerseys with large block purple numbers and purple pants with double white stripes down the side.
Next to that shot is “Backfire”, Ed Bailey going 40 yards with the interception that gave SU its second touchdown. The last possible tackler is sprawled on the turf, five yards behind him and he is galloping, knees high, toward the end zone. Linemen in those days were not much bigger than backs so Bailey didn’t “lumber” like today’s 300 pounders would have. He ran. Below that we see Jim Brown jumping into the back of Dick Archand in the end zone as the pass that Archand “caught” for the Crusader’s second score, arrives. That’s a close-up shot from the back of the end zone. Next to that is a broad shot of Bill Smithers on his 33 yard fake pass and bootleg from the HC 12 to the 45 in the first period. He’s holding the ball far out from his body and he takes evasive maneuvers, as well he might. There’s one defender immediately to his left and three more right behind him. He’s on the 20 yard line and got to the 45 so the evasive maneuvers worked.
The Post Standard had a shot of Jim Brown being tackled after a 30 yard run in that drive where he gained 70 and scored his only TD. It’s taken from the front and HC’s Gordon Massa is hugging his hips while Jim tried to push him away with one of his famous straight-arms. But he can’t quite get it straight on this occasion. The Post Standard shots are lighter than the Herald’s and it can be more easily seen that the Orange is in orange.
The PS sports page had a classic shot that I’ve looked at for years without knowing what game it was from. It appears on page 195 of Ken Rappoport’s “The Syracuse Football Story”, which I got when it came out in 1975. There the caption reads “A game of the 1950’s and two Syracuse players are on the ball- Chuck Strid and Ed Bailey.” I’ve spent four decades wondering which game of the 50’s it was. It was this game. The picture shows the Smithers’ fumble into the end zone. This one is taken from behind the goal line but to the side, (the Herald shot is from the top of the stadium and behind the paly, also a bit later in the play). The ball is out and has bounced across the goal line. Strid and Bailey see it and are just starting to react, (Cashman is obscured by a referee who is the only thing between the three players and the ball.) The picture has those wonderful additions the paper always added including the inevitable “goal line” sign. We see a dotted line from where the ball was fumbled into the end zone, an arrow at the end pointing to a circle with the bouncing ball inside of it. Strid and Bailey have their own signs identifying them.
Below that is a shot of Jim Ridlon, racing directly toward the camera, which is behind the end zone, on his second period TD reception. He looks like a very determined fumble and I wouldn’t have wanted to try to tackle him. On Page 34 We see Dick Bernadino turning to take Tom Greene’s pass over the head of Ed Ackley for their first score. The next page is another shot of Jim Brown scoring on that sweep. We can now see that the man being blocked was Dale Hohl, who is on the ground here as Tom Greene runs along the goal line to try to stop Brown but Jimmy is just a step away.
The famous Sports Illustrated cover shot of Chuck Zimmerman, which was on their 10/27/58 cover is actually a cropped version of a picture taken from the 11/10/56 Holy Cross game:
http://cdn2.sbnation.com/fan_shot_images/254717/AthyvhZCIAAxTlL.jpg
Bill Reddy’s Monday column told a story about Ben Schwartzwalder. Holy Cross’s Dr. Eddie Anderson had played for Knute Rockne in the 20’s and Ben had nearly played for Rockne, too. The great man had heard about Ben’s play in high school in west Virginia and came to see him play. Ben was only a 148 pound, (I kid you not) lineman but Rockne, who’d based his teams on speed, rather than size, wasn’t concerned. He offered Ben an opportunity to come and play for him at Notre Dame. “After Rock’s visit, I was walking on air”. But Ben’s father died shortly afterwards and he wanted to stay closer to home. So he went to West Virginia and started for three years. But he never forgot his meeting with Knute Rockne.
Reddy reported that Avatus Stone had been in attendance at the game. He’d become a star in Canadian football, largely due to his exceptional punting. But an old leg injury he had first sustained at SU had flared up and he was here to get it examined.
Arnie Burdick helped the Old Scout put up his storm windows while they discussed the game. The OS was pleased with the improved passing attack. I thought Chuck Zimmerman looked looser and more confident yesterday… he looked more like the boy who riddled the Maryland defenses with his passes in the opening game of the season.“ Part of it was Dr. Anderson’s decision to put seven men on the line of scrimmage to try to stop Jim Brown.
The Old Scout continued to be impressed with Jim Ridlon. “It looked to me , too, that Jim Ridlon was having his best day. He did so many things well. He threw passes, caught them knocked them down, intercepted them . He punted dead to the 12, which set up our fifth TD and almost broke away for a long touchdown run early in the second half, when he fumbled with what looked like a clear field ahead. He was changing the ball from one arm to the other, when he was about to cut back and got hit.” A San Francisco 49er scout, Joe Ventrano, was in attendance and “was talking to himself about Ridlon”. The 49ers would draft Jim in the 4th round of the 1957 NFL Draft and he played for them for 6 years.
He also praised the other Jim, Brown. “His fourth quarter performance yesterday looked like a repeat of his late rush in the West Virginia game. Something seemed to snap inside of him when they ruled that the Holy Cross end had held the ball long enough in the end zone for a score. Jim just seemed to step up the pace another notch or two and say “Give me the ball- I’ll run right over ‘em ‘till I score.” On his longest jaunt on that surge – 30 yards – the Syracuse blocker who was supposed to take the end forgot to pull. That didn’t bother Jimmy: he just blew him right over. Maybe that’s what we ought to call him, especially with all of this cold weather and snow that’s on the way: THE BROWN BLIZZARD, THE WIZARD OF ORANGE.”
The Scout was pleased with our opportunistic pass defense but felt that it’s biggest challenge would be against Colgate’s Guy martin the next week, whom he rather above both Milt Plum and Bill Smithers because of his accuracy and deft ball-handling. “It should be a high-scoring, action-packed game, the kind the fans like to see.”