This article has some interesting quotes by Buck Showalter on the roster limits:
On Thursday, each Major League Baseball team will have the luxury of adding a few players to their active roster. Buck Showalter has mixed feelings about the whole ordeal. “I remember years a…
www.ocregister.com
"September call-ups aren’t what they used to be — teams are now required to have 28 players once the calendar hits Sept. 1 — instead of being able to go all the way up to 40 like the old days. Of those 28 players, only 14 can be pitchers. Buck Showalter has mixed feelings about the whole ordeal.
“I remember years ago when we eliminated Boston with a 37 or 38-man roster,” Showalter said, remembering his time in Baltimore. “I enjoyed winning the game, but I felt bad. Seriously! There was no way we could have competed with them with 25. But at 37, with six left-handed pitchers and six right-handed sidearmers, it wasn’t fair. It wasn’t right.”
With a new team under his wing, knowing that some extra help here and there would really go a long way, he’s aiming for a compromise. “Now that I’m in this position, I wish it was 30 instead of 28,” he admitted. “I’m glad that we got it down. But, now that I’m here, I wish it was 30.”
Showalter also pointed out that if the rosters went to 30 players, or as high as 35, it’d be much easier to give young minor leaguers a traditional audition. Now, with so few to choose from, the club’s hands are tied. The limited choices, plus being in a pennant race, means whoever gets called up will be expected to contribute rather than just test their stuff out in the big leagues.
“It’s hard,” Showalter conceded. “I think these are guys that are going to come in and contribute. It’s almost like a competitive thing more than wanting to know. I do miss that part, the curiosity, just seeing them in the locker room and BP and this environment. That’s kind of lost.”
Considering the expansion of both the starting rotation and the bullpen staff as well as the shrinkage of the minor leagues, why not just pus the roster limit up to 30 and make it that for every month? In the old days we had 4 man rotations and the top reliever was both a fireman and a closer who could pitch multiple innings. teams would have about 10 pitchers and 15 position players. you could have three catchers, two utility infielders, a couple of back-up outfielders and a pinch hitter. Nowadays they have 13-14 pitchers with the bench reduced to 3-4 players. Why not acknowledge the way the game has changed and push it to 30?