OrangeXtreme
The Mayor of Dewitt
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 234,968
- Like
- 427,667
Hard to ask specific questions about football when you can't see practice.I hate to be that guy but some football questions would be awesome too
Hard to ask specific questions about football when you can't see practice.
I see where you're going, but from a reporting perspective:Agree but lets ask about the new coordinators...
1. How has the adjustments been for you personally?
2. Whats been the biggest change under Coach X
3. How is your role changing under your new coordinator?
4. What do you like best under the new Offensive scheme?
5. Do you see your role different as a TE with Coach Gilbert?
6. How has the playbook changed?
Still lots to talk about despite not seeing the practices...
Shouldn't you ask just in case you get a little bit of information? The COVID stuff is obviously important to report on, but man, as a consumer I'm begging for some football news.I see where you're going, but from a reporting perspective:
1 and 2 are only of value for a writer who is writing a piece about the new coordinator.
3-6 are not worth asking. Babers runs a tight ship, and they're not going to give a worthwhile answer to questions that deal with tactics / philosophy in summer camp. All the beat writers have been around long enough to recognize that.
I mean, I don't know what the story planning process is for Mink and Bailey. I also haven't watched the presser to the extent of what was asked.Shouldn't you ask just in case you get a little bit of information? The COVID stuff is obviously important to report on, but man, as a consumer I'm begging for some football news.
Benson is a very young player to be talking to media, yeah?
I see where you're going, but from a reporting perspective:
1 and 2 are only of value for a writer who is writing a piece about the new coordinator.
3-6 are not worth asking. Babers runs a tight ship, and they're not going to give a worthwhile answer to questions that deal with tactics / philosophy in summer camp. All the beat writers have been around long enough to recognize that.
I get it. In my line of work, number 1 question is audience. Who are they, what do they want, what data should we give them based on that.I mean, I don't know what the story planning process is for Mink and Bailey. I also haven't watched the presser to the extent of what was asked.
That said, a journalist goes into a presser with a story or stories in mind. With all of the questions about the season and if it will happen, plus the players sitting out of practice (which is a HUGE story that needs to be unpacked), there is plenty that needs to be covered.
Writing about actual football is, of course, what we all want. But it's super hard to get a useful answer from a player when you can't ask a specific question about what you've seen.
I'm sure their #1 question is also audience. But several things:I get it. In my line of work, number 1 question is audience. Who are they, what do they want, what data should we give them based on that.
I would think most of the football audience they are attracting do care about COVID and practicing/playing games. but would also like to hear some targeted questions about new coaches and personnel.
Yeah, but without the fans (readers/subscribers) the press don't have jobs. I guess I'm naive, but the sports press should always be asking questions to create interesting articles that subscribers want to read or that lead to future interesting articles that fans (readers/subscribers) want to subscribe for. So if the time is just for press to ask questions, I don't get the distinction between their questions and questions we want attempted to be answered. Now certainly I'm not saying for them to read off a card, "city of cuse from parts unknown would like to ask Luke how many hamburgers he can eat."I'm sure their #1 question is also audience. But several things:
1) These press conferences are for the press to ask questions. The athletic department replays them because fans like them. But they're for the press, not the fans.
2) The players aren't going to answer those questions - Dino keeps everything super close to the vest this time of year. And when the media can't see even glimpses of practices, there's really no use in asking general questions. Side-stepped answers don't make for great articles.
This is not supposed to sound personal, just an observation based on my experience as a former news producer, as well as my wife's - who has sports beat writing experience.Yeah, but without the fans (readers/subscribers) the press don't have jobs. I guess I'm naive, but the sports press should always be asking questions to create interesting articles that subscribers want to read or that lead to future interesting articles that fans (readers/subscribers) want to subscribe for.
Describe the challenges that occur when a new coach comes into a program? Has the team recovered from the let down last season. I'm obviously spit balling and I'm no journalist, just seems like they could take some constructive criticism from subscribers.
Media are supposed to be the lifelines to the teams they are covering for fans.This is not supposed to sound personal, just an observation based on my experience as a former news producer, as well as my wife's - who has sports beat writing experience.
For a reporter to ask how practice is going and the adjustments are going and other general optimism stuff five days after a report from The Athletic's beat writer made us all question if there was going to be Syracuse football this year is a bad look because it's ignoring the actual stories. Those stories being player unity, player concerns, handling of testing, spiking rates at multiple Syracuse opponents, and how they're actually going to do this safely. The fact that players may sit out for Liberty because of COVID concerns is a far bigger potential story than the team adapting to the 3-3-5.
Hype stories and previews are filler for anything else to talk about. While fun, there's much bigger news happening right now.
And personally, I care far more about whether or not there will be a season than how the team looks at the moment. Because if the team doesn't take the field this fall, what does it matter?
Why can't it be both? I'm not saying ignore the COVID story, but do what the fans want.This is not supposed to sound personal, just an observation based on my experience as a former news producer, as well as my wife's - who has sports beat writing experience.
For a reporter to ask how practice is going and the adjustments are going and other general optimism stuff five days after a report from The Athletic's beat writer made us all question if there was going to be Syracuse football this year is a bad look because it's ignoring the actual stories. Those stories being player unity, player concerns, handling of testing, spiking rates at multiple Syracuse opponents, and how they're actually going to do this safely. The fact that players may sit out for Liberty because of COVID concerns is a far bigger potential story than the team adapting to the 3-3-5.
Hype stories and previews are filler for anything else to talk about. While fun, there's much bigger news happening right now.
And personally, I care far more about whether or not there will be a season than how the team looks at the moment. Because if the team doesn't take the field this fall, what does it matter?
I was in the industry. Pay was terrible and the hours are awful.Why can't it be both? I'm not saying ignore the COVID story, but do what the fans want.
You're in the industry so it is close to you, but try to look at it from another view. I'm a consumer and I'm telling you what I want and what at least a few others in this thread want and you are telling me no. Seems odd, why not say okay we will add a couple more articles about football, the actual sport being played.
Hey wait a second, I'm just here to complain, not actually trying to take action and contacting people!I was in the industry. Pay was terrible and the hours are awful.
I get what you're saying. Just telling you, from an informed perspective, why something is the way it is.
That said, contact info for editors and reporters isn't hard to find.