Andy Katz with no respect for Red and Judah

[JoeSU]

This breakdown and all the questions many teams above us have shows just how these early rankings are pointless and mostly carrying over last year's successes.

Men's college basketball rosters: Comings and goings for 2023-24

Your guide to all the player movement for the top conferences and programs, including transfers, recruits and NBA draft decisions.

www.espn.com

Case in point: Katz's predication at this time last year didn't even have Miami making the Tourney. Now, after making a run to the Final 4, he the Canes as a 2 Seed, despite losing 2 of their better players (as Cuse 99&01 points out).

 

[007]

We were hot garbage the past two seasons. If I was a neutral observer, I wouldn't give us the benefit of the doubt either until we actually start winning games on the court. Which as a fan I'm personally confident we will do.

Yeah, we made the bed we currently lie in. You have to prove it on the court. It’s as simple as that. There is no real “lack of respect” here IMO. Any respect given would be nothing more than blind faith.

 

[gmoney44]

Katz is going to smoke a turd in hell for that slight! Kidding aside who cares? It's not like he is Nostradamus. I am fine with proving we are back first. It makes it all the more satisfying.

I’d rather be underrated to start the season so the team has a chip on their shoulder for that early season gauntlet we have.

 

[Lukeyloo]

And a schmuck and a putz.

As well as a doofus and a dingbat

 

[rrlbees]

I’d rather be underrated to start the season so the team has a chip on their shoulder for that early season gauntlet we have.

The 2003 team wasn’t ranked preseason.

 

[OrangeDW]

Rational part of me says that we need to see Red’s Xs and Os before we get assumed credit.

The irrational part of me says that he’s an idiot and we’re going to put the world on notice when we run thru Maui and come out ranked the #1 team in the country.

X’ sand O’s and how he manages the game, subs, timeouts, etc - all important and we’ll see how he does.

But having a clear vision for how he wants to play, and being able to successfully put together a roster to execute it…..that’s a very good sign that he seems to be nailing the “big picture” stuff. It’s also a great sign that how he seemingly wants to play matches where the sport has gone in recent years.

Guards dominate the game, and having numerous good ball handlers and athletic perimeter defenders is an absolute must, and just watching any of the teams that have actually been good is all that’s needed to see that.

 

[TheHaze315]

Katz doesn’t know his azz from his elbow. Especially not in June.

 

[cliftonparksufan]

Syracuse was bad last season. They're not going to get the benefit of the doubt this early.

Who cares [not directed at the OP, clifton]?

We weren't very good last year, the perception is that we lost several key players, and Red is unproven.

Up to us to dispel that narrative and serve notice to the rest of the country. IMO, we have a lot to prove.

IMO #2 -- we have the squad to accomplish that goal.

I don't disagree with you guys, but its the portal era. For a lot of teams what happened last year means nothing as so many parts will have changed. And if Red is half the coach as he is a recruiter, I feel pretty good about our chances. Our players will be ready to prove a lot next year.

Question for RF(and anyone): We all would have like to have seen Hop as our coach five ago. That never happened, so would you still have preferred Hop (and the same assistant coaches) or are you 100% all in with how the last two months have transpired.

Is there any holdouts for Hop or Jay Wright still?

 

[OrangeDW]

I don't disagree with you guys, but its the portal era. For a lot of teams what happened last year means nothing as so many parts will have changed. And if Red is half the coach as he is a recruiter, I feel pretty good about our chances. Our players will be ready to prove a lot next year.

Question for RF(and anyone): We all would have like to have seen Hop as our coach five ago. That never happened, so would you still have preferred Hop (and the same assistant coaches) or are you 100% all in with how the last two months have transpired.

Is there any holdouts for Hop or Jay Wright still?

Hop is still playing mostly zone, right?

If so - I don’t get it, and that makes me not want him.

 

[Orangezoo]

I don't disagree with you guys, but its the portal era. For a lot of teams what happened last year means nothing as so many parts will have changed. And if Red is half the coach as he is a recruiter, I feel pretty good about our chances. Our players will be ready to prove a lot next year.

Question for RF(and anyone): We all would have like to have seen Hop as our coach five ago. That never happened, so would you still have preferred Hop (and the same assistant coaches) or are you 100% all in with how the last two months have transpired.

Is there any holdouts for Hop or Jay Wright still?

Based on the evolution of the kids and the game, withholding some judgment until we see in game coaching I feel Red is the right guy. I do think he was the right guy a couple years ago though too not this late but that's a moot point now.

 

[Jzsshuttles]

Syracuse was bad last season. They're not going to get the benefit of the doubt this early.

Syracuse wasn’t bad. They were young. Big difference

 

[AZOrange]

Oh good another thing I don’t care about

 

[SanDiegoCuse]

I believe Katz is a JB loyalist. Whatevs…

 

[Orangezoo]

Syracuse wasn’t bad. They were young. Big difference

Youngish and mediocre to bad. We started two seniors.

 

[hoopsupstate]

To be listed as the third team out is a huge improvement over last year. We were nowhere to be found last season. I have a bigger issue with only five ACC teams listed. That’s a even bigger snub.

 

[Jzsshuttles]

Youngish and mediocre to bad. We started two seniors.

Bad early. Really bad. The team played solid ball for a long stretch

 

[DoctorBombay]

Predictions are among the more worthless things that humans do.

That, and speculation. Cable news shows favorite pastime of " let's sit here and guess what we think might happen". Aaargh!

 

[CapitalO]

Word is, he’s an idiot and a disloyal person.

That's what I have been saying for years.

 

[sufandu]

Isn't it a complment that he has us in the first 4 out? That's significantly better than how we actually finished the previous two years. He thinks we'll be better.

 

[sufandu]

Syracuse wasn’t bad. They were young. Big difference

Youth really isn't a legit reason anymore. Every year there are really good teams that are younger than we were and the days of expecting young guys to stick around and develop are all but over.

 

[cuseallday]

I think this roster, on paper, is really exciting with loads of potential. SU was 33-32 the past two years. It lost two of its top three scorers. I think SU will be better than 17-15 this year, but I don't think it's a surprise that Andy and others aren't including SU in their early mock fields of 68 and/or preseason top-25 rankings. First-year head coach. Lots of roster comings and goings. No player is above his junior year. Let's win Maui and vault into the top 10!

 

[IthacaMatt]

I predict that I will have my first beer this afternoon, about 30 minutes prior to my 4:30pm tee time, with many more to follow. I am hardly ever wrong with these kinds of predictions.

First beer at 4PM? It's a weekend, y'know!

 

[MMXmusic]

In a way, "We have them right where we want them," i.e., under the radar. Recall that SU's 2002-03 NC team was outside the Top 25 in pre-season rankings. My belief is that the more the media ignores/downplays this Orange squad pre-season, during, and in post-season bracket forecasting, the better. Red and the guys could use it as a challenge to be the best they can be.

 

[gmoney44]

Youngish and mediocre to bad. We started two seniors.

We were and have been bad for a while. I’m excited for basketball for the first time in years.

Like Andy Dufresne once said “hope is good thing.”

 

[sufandu]

I think this roster, on paper, is really exciting with loads of potential. SU was 33-32 the past two years. It lost two of its top three scorers. I think SU will be better than 17-15 this year, but I don't think it's a surprise that Andy and others aren't including SU in their early mock fields of 68 and/or preseason top-25 rankings. First-year head coach. Lots of roster comings and goings. No player is above his junior year. Let's win Maui and vault into the top 10!

And even though Red has added a lot of athleticism to the roster, nobody was added that has already had proven success like Kansas adding Dickinson. Lot's of potential combined with uncertainty.