I can kinda see it both ways. Last year, there were many times I thought to myself, why are people criticizing Judah so hard. There was sooooo much talk about him falling down, even after a game in which he scored a lot and contributed significantly. So I tend to agree that he gets more criticism than maybe is warranted.
That said, part of what leads to the criticism is his lack of involving others on plays more and just looking to score, so much complaining on the court, not getting back on D at times, comments he's made after games, slapping an opponent, and not really showing that much improvement from last year. Right or wrong, those are things I've read from others and felt myself.
When the dust settles though, I will root for Judah as loudly as any other cuse player. He's family and I wish him and the team the best. I doubt you can come up with one person on this board who isn't a Judah fan, even with some of the criticism.