Coach Search Options after Autry

[PhatOrange]

I'd love to hear your reasoning why it's a no brainer. I would take Albany or Syracuse over Boston any day. There are plenty of nice neighborhoods in the Capital Region and CNY to offset anything Boston can offer.

Boston is one of the last places I'd want to live.

 

[phil77]

That wasn't my question. They are in first place. They must have guys playing well. You said he was recruiting top tier talent. I asked what top tier talent he recruited as a Head Coach?

Are you saying that he wasn't considered a top tier recuiter? I don't understand what you are asking or trying to prove? You can't be suggesting that he isn't an elite recruiter because he isn't bringing in top tier NBA talent to those schools right?

Nelson, Enis, and Pinson are all P4 level players that he has recruited to stay at a lower level to play for him.

 

[CuseFan]

I want a coach that is going to have an clear offense, but also strong defense that drives a run and gun fast break machine. Let's make basketball fun again!

 

[UpstateSM]

That wasn't my question. They are in first place. They must have guys playing well. You said he was recruiting top tier talent. I asked what top tier talent he recruited as a Head Coach?

Composite four star high schooler at Arkansas St. Three of their top four highest rated recruits of all time. Composite four star high schooler and a four star transfer (five star out of high school) at USF. All per 247.

 

[dasher]

Are you saying that he wasn't considered a top tier recuiter? I don't understand what you are asking or trying to prove? You can't be suggesting that he isn't an elite recruiter because he isn't bringing in top tier NBA talent to those schools right?

Nelson, Enis, and Pinson are all P4 level players that he has recruited to stay at a lower level to play for him.

You said he was a top tier recruiter. I asked what top tier talent has he recruited as a Head coach? A rather simple question. The answer I guess is none. He was as an ass't at Alabama. Since he has been gone, they have continued to recruit a high level. I think he is going to be the guy almost by default. I am warning of over rating him.

 

[Cuse1055]

I will say Autry’s best attribute is as a recruiter and look where that’s gotten us.

 

[dasher]

Composite four star high schooler at Arkansas St. Three of their top four highest rated recruits of all time. Composite four star high schooler and a four star transfer (five star out of high school) at USF. All per 247.

That is fine. Not what I would call top tier but for them, great. I just asked what top tier talent he brought in as a Head coach. We have two 5 star players on this team. So...

 

[dasher]

Agree and also strongly believe the level of talent will increase as he moves up the ranks.

I would bet on that. It better. I think we are in the new girlfriend phase. Anything she does is a lot better than the old girlfriend. Until it isn't.

 

[Cuse2023]

That is fine. Not what I would call top tier but for them, great. I just asked what top tier talent he brought in as a Head coach. We have two 5 star players on this team. So...

Did you expect him to recruit five-star players at Arkansas State and South Florida?

He had the highest-ranked recruit in Arkansas State history and the third-highest-ranked recruit in South Florida history in his first season.

 

[rrlbees]

You said he was a top tier recruiter. I asked what top tier talent has he recruited as a Head coach? A rather simple question. The answer I guess is none. He was as an ass't at Alabama. Since he has been gone, they have continued to recruit a high level. I think he is going to be the guy almost by default. I am warning of over rating him.

regardless of the coach i think bama kinda recruits themself with all their nil.

 

[PhatOrange]

Is there any other P4 program that's hiring or even seriously considering hiring any of them this offseason?

No. Of course not.

 

[dasher]

regardless of the coach i think bama kinda recruits themself with all their nil.

And even before NIL, I don't believe Oats has ever been bothered by rules.

 

[Cuse1055]

In the NIL day and age, recruiting doesn’t matter as much. However if you can coach and recruit to your system, then you have a higher likelihood of success.

 

[PhatOrange]

I'm not sold on Hodgson but while people question what talent has he brought in as a head coach it's probably a better sign that he's winning without it.

 

[phil77]

In Bama they went

2019 - 11th (late to the cycle)
2020 -13th
2021 -1st
2022 -2nd
2023 -1st (Yes, Bryan Hodgson was heavily involved in recruiting for the University of Alabama men's basketball program leading up to the 2023 season, acting as a top recruiter and assistant coach under Nate Oats. He was responsible for bringing in major talent, including signing the 2022-23 team's key players, before departing for Arkansas State in March 2023.)


2024 - 2nd (Hodgson starting contacting recruits but other assistants took over when he left)
2025 - 15th (247) - 4th (on3) -19th (espn) - 11th (rivals)

So Bama is having a little dip now that Hodgson isn't recruiting full-time...

 

[dasher]

Did you expect him to recruit five-star players at Arkansas State and South Florida?

He had the highest-ranked recruit in Arkansas State history and the third-highest-ranked recruit in South Florida history in his first season.

I didn't expect him to do anything. I was just asking a question.

 

[orangepassion]

I didn't expect him to do anything. I was just asking a question.

Did you order the Code Red? No, but Wildhack will.

 

[dasher]

In Bama they went

2019 - 11th (late to the cycle)
2020 -13th
2021 -1st
2022 -2nd
2023 -1st (Yes, Bryan Hodgson was heavily involved in recruiting for the University of Alabama men's basketball program leading up to the 2023 season, acting as a top recruiter and assistant coach under Nate Oats. He was responsible for bringing in major talent, including signing the 2022-23 team's key players, before departing for Arkansas State in March 2023.)


2024 - 2nd (Hodgson starting contacting recruits but other assistants took over when he left)
2025 - 15th (247) - 4th (on3) -19th (espn) - 11th (rivals)

So Bama is having a little dip now that Hodgson isn't recruiting full-time...

I'll be honest, it disturbs me that this is the best that we can do. If it is. For me, it is an uninspiring lot. Unless a certain booster throws say 10 million in to NIL. Then I am all on board.

 

[dasher]

Did you order the Code Red? No, but Wildhack will.

I did my job. I would do it again

 

[phil77]

I'll be honest, it disturbs me that this is the best that we can do. If it is.

I have said many times I think there are a few better coaches on the market but Hodgson as a floor isn't bad. He is currently more qualified than GMac and it disturbs me how many are good with GMac being our head coach.

 

[dasher]

I have said many times I think there are a few better coaches on the market but Hodgson as a floor isn't bad. He is currently more qualified than GMac and it disturbs me how many are good with GMac being our head coach.

I haven't seen many that are good with that. I know Gerry himself isn't all that good with it.

 

[rrlbees]

Alums-plural. Yes.

yep. alum, non-alum. regional, national. i think most, maybe not all, are going to ask about resources/nil available regardless of how they think of themselves as a fundraiser. let's say $10m is the "magic" number. it's a lot easier to get to $10m from $7m or $8m than it is from $5m.

 

[littlereg]

regardless of the coach i think bama kinda recruits themself with all their nil.

Prior to Oats Alabama had been to the tournament twice since 2006. I do 100% agree Alabama in the NIL era recruits itself but they were just another football school playing basketball until he got there.

 

[dasher]

yep. alum, non-alum. regional, national. i think most, maybe not all, are going to ask about resources/nil available regardless of how they think of themselves as a fundraiser. let's say $10m is the "magic" number. it's a lot easier to get to $10m from $7m or $8m than it is from $5m.

It's the reason I turned it down

 

[Cuse2023]

I didn't expect him to do anything. I was just asking a question.

Okay, well I would say that's pretty top tier.