Duke QB to Miami? Resolution reached | Page 13 | Syracusefan.com

Duke QB to Miami? Resolution reached

Can Mensah sit out this year and play next year at Miami? Spend the year learning their playbook and keeping active with workouts, etc until his current agreement expires?
 
Can Mensah sit out this year and play next year at Miami? Spend the year learning their playbook and keeping active with workouts, etc until his current agreement expires?
I think he would need to go to class, maintain his grades, but can’t be officially paid unless Duke lets him out of his contract. Not sure if sitting out the year serves his interests.
 
Can Mensah sit out this year and play next year at Miami? Spend the year learning their playbook and keeping active with workouts, etc until his current agreement expires?
6 credits in a semester and 24 in a calendar year to be eligible. If Duke fails him for every course he could potentially be eligible by 2028-29 season if he enrolled at Miami and took classes all of 27-28 while not being a member of the football team.

Hope these situations start playing out as such. The U can pay him 2 years to potentially play 1 and Duke can sue for breach of contract recouping all money's, including scholarship room and board, that they paid/spent on Mensah.

Hope this happens with the Clemson/Ole Miss LB and the USCe/Cuse/Ole Miss TE as well. Schools getting robbed should end up paying 0 to players and making bank off Schools that rob them. Precedent needs to be set
 
I think he would need to go to class, maintain his grades, but can’t be officially paid unless Duke lets him out of his contract. Not sure if sitting out the year serves his interests.
All of the above...and he cannot enroll in any other school not named Duke (Dook for our ACC friends). Obviously that does not factor in the NCAA's ineptitude which, for the right Miami pu$ua$ian may not involve actual oversight.
 
I wouldn’t I would want 15 mil. If Miami gonna be dumb then perfect. Cough it all up plus extra for stupidity.
that's why i think it works. Buyout, Portal Fee, etc whatever you want to call it. Teams develop players and can recoup some $$$ for it. The whole system stinks but it's better than losing these guys for nothing.
 
that's why i think it works. Buyout, Portal Fee, etc whatever you want to call it. Teams develop players and can recoup some $$$ for it. The whole system stinks but it's better than losing these guys for nothing.
They could also include a bonus buyout if a kid leaves in the last three days of the portal period.
 
that's why i think it works. Buyout, Portal Fee, etc whatever you want to call it. Teams develop players and can recoup some $$$ for it. The whole system stinks but it's better than losing these guys for nothing.
Are you thinking that some schools do the heavy recruiting in High School, develop the players, with the cream moving on to the higher levels? Are you think a two-, three-, or four tiered system? Develop the idea, this may actually work.

I would Hope SU ends in the top tier, though.
 
I wouldn’t I would want 15 mil. If Miami gonna be dumb then perfect. Cough it all up plus extra for stupidity.
No no no no no. How could you let a star player walk, then go back to the team, to all the others who have worked so hard, perhaps even some who transferred in to play with that star player, and say, sorry guys, John Q is gone but we did get a hundred million dollars, which none of you are going to see any of, and oh by the way we can't back-fill that star player's position at all?

No no no no, while you have the power to refuse to breach the contract, you do so, and I'd love to see the authorities deployed to physically block players from trying to breach the contract unilaterally. Lock em up if it comes to that.

Yeah I am super salty about this whole thing.
 
Are you thinking that some schools do the heavy recruiting in High School, develop the players, with the cream moving on to the higher levels? Are you think a two-, three-, or four tiered system? Develop the idea, this may actually work.

I would Hope SU ends in the top tier, though.
Much like European soccer, there are many clubs that are better at finding and developing "diamond in the rough" players. Those players do well and often get sold to mega clubs for large fees. The money is then re-invested into scouting and buying players from levels below them.

My theory is that in this system, boosters would finally reduce spend because their money would actually help other schools.
 
No no no no no. How could you let a star player walk, then go back to the team, to all the others who have worked so hard, perhaps even some who transferred in to play with that star player, and say, sorry guys, John Q is gone but we did get a hundred million dollars, which none of you are going to see any of, and oh by the way we can't back-fill that star player's position at all?

No no no no, while you have the power to refuse to breach the contract, you do so, and I'd love to see the authorities deployed to physically block players from trying to breach the contract unilaterally. Lock em up if it comes to that.

Yeah I am super salty about this whole thing.
U make good points no doubt. My only thought was why not use that money on a new qb next year and some other players that would put them over the top.
 
No no no no no. How could you let a star player walk, then go back to the team, to all the others who have worked so hard, perhaps even some who transferred in to play with that star player, and say, sorry guys, John Q is gone but we did get a hundred million dollars, which none of you are going to see any of, and oh by the way we can't back-fill that star player's position at all?

No no no no, while you have the power to refuse to breach the contract, you do so, and I'd love to see the authorities deployed to physically block players from trying to breach the contract unilaterally. Lock em up if it comes to that.

Yeah I am super salty about this whole thing.
We are all super salty about this. Agreed, force the issue and watch the kid sit out, have to pay back anything he has received because he refused to play and failed to enroll in school. Watch his stock drop and face the reality of the cold, cruel world that he tried to play on the team he is breaching.
 
Much like European soccer, there are many clubs that are better at finding and developing "diamond in the rough" players. Those players do well and often get sold to mega clubs for large fees. The money is then re-invested into scouting and buying players from levels below them.

My theory is that in this system, boosters would finally reduce spend because their money would actually help other schools.
Does this create a permanent upper curst which can rarely if ever be achieved by the masses? If so, I prefer the MLB system and force the major NFL and NBA teams to develop minor leagues fully or align with X number of universities, limiting each team to no more than one within each conference.
 


Full Tweet:

Here's Duke's statement on Darian Mensah settlement: “Duke University Athletics and Darian Mensah have reached a resolution that enables both parties to move forward. We are committed to fulfilling all promises and obligations Duke makes to our student-athletes when we enter into contractual agreements with them, and we expect the same in return. Enforcing those agreements is a necessary element of ensuring predictability and structure for athletic programs. It is nonetheless a difficult choice to pursue legal action against a student and teammate; for this reason we sought to resolve the matter fairly and quickly. Duke remains dedicated to the welfare of all student-athletes, and we appreciate them for the talent, dedication, and commitment to excellence they demonstrate both on and off the field. We also remain committed to upholding the integrity of our athletics programs and institutional guidelines. We thank Darian for his contributions to Duke University.”
 

Forum statistics

Threads
176,027
Messages
5,287,991
Members
6,195
Latest member
BackTo315

Online statistics

Members online
376
Guests online
2,789
Total visitors
3,165


P
Top Bottom